Changeset: 127365338
NVDB highway import for Härnösand
Closed by Msiipola
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (18570 en) |
---|---|
source | Trafikverket NVDB, Mapbox Satellite, Lantmäteriet |
Discussion
-
Comment from Mateusz Konieczny
Is it a discussed import?
If yes - can you link OSM Wiki page of that import?
(and please, include such link in future edits)
-
Comment from Msiipola
Yes, it's a ongoing import and it has been approved several years ago.
https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Import/Catalogue/Sweden_highway_import
Please ask the team leader about details:
https://www.openstreetmap.org/user/torgerI don't understand your comment about including link. I have include upload comments according the import instructions.
-
Comment from Mateusz Konieczny
> I have include upload comments according the import instructions.
In such case import instructions are deficient and badly planned - import edits and bot edits should link back to documentation pages
-
Comment from Msiipola
As I said, I'm not the lead of the project. If you have complaints how this project is controlled, please discuss this with user "torger".
I only follow the instructions. -
Comment from Msiipola
Maybe you misunderstands how the work is done.
There is no automatic replacement of import data. Alla changes are done manually one by one, using the Swedish road database as a reference. -
Comment from torger
Hello Mateusz, the NVDB project has been ongoing for a couple of years and is well known in the Swedish OSM community and has been discussed according to the OSM process for imports. You can contact me if you have any questions. Note that it is not an traditional automated import, ie it's manual work, all road segments are merged manually, and manually changed as needed. 100 segments takes about 1 hour manual work to go through, in a city with complex pre-existing mapping, 4 hours. One medium-sized municipality takes about 60 - 80 hour manual work to go through. By not having to click out every node the work is about 10 times faster than 100% manual work, and we get more tags like speed limits and such from the high quality government provided open database NVDB. This is necessary to increase the quality of OSM mapping in Sweden as we have many rural areas with very low density of local mappers and thus poor pre-existing quality.
Because of the highly manual process, no special import accounts are used, just our normal accounts.
You can see the current progress here:
https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Import/Catalogue/Sweden_highway_import/Progress -
Comment from Mateusz Konieczny
@torget Can you modify instructions and ask people to link https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Import/Catalogue/Sweden_highway_import/Progress as part of changeset description or as an extra changeset tag?
This way this apparently discussed and welcome import can be distinguished from wild ones without bothering people with changeset comments
- 692383025, v3
- 692383044, v7
- 693161795, v5
- Torromvägen (693161796), v3
- 693163554, v2
- 693163555, v2
- 693163764, v2
- 693163765, v4
- 693163843, v2
- Stortallsvägen (693164640), v2
- 693165029, v2
- 693165610, v4
- 693238144, v2
- 693313973, v3
- 693314945, v8
- 693315081, v4
- Hästmyrhalsenvägen (693318013), v6
- Kojbergetvägen (693319646), v2
- 693364307, v2
- 693364308, v2
Relations (1-20 of 35)
- 1
- 2
- E 4 Västernorrlands län (1361230), v321
- Y 693 (1378908), v7
- Y 696 (1379865), v14
- Y 697 (1379866), v7
- Y 698 (1379871), v3
- Y 708 (1379876), v7
- Y 710 (1380541), v11
- Buss 100: Sundsvall => Umeå (2628942), v264
- Buss 100: Umeå => Sundsvall (2628943), v268
- Buss 201: Sundsvall => Härnösand (2628985), v130
- Buss 201: Härnösand => Sundsvall (2629072), v134
- Buss 98: Sundsvall => Härnösand => Kramfors => Sollefteå (2925250), v181
- Buss 98: Sollefteå => Kramfors => Härnösand => Sundsvall (2925251), v185
- 9196584, v299
- 9196585, v355
- 9296638, v4
- 9403909, v2
- Buss 520 Härnösand => Häggdånger => Härnösand (10046148), v13
- Flixbus K614: Sollefteå, Resecentrum => Stockholm Cityterminalen (10928238), v74
- Flixbus K614: Stockholm Cityterminalen => Sollefteå, Resecentrum (10928239), v76
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |