Changeset: 134550384
JOSM data validation
Closed by Spaghetti Monster🍝
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (18678 en) |
---|---|
source | Bing; Maxar Premium Imagery |
Discussion
-
Comment from tguen
Wow... there is a lot going on here for a single changeset. Too much IMO. It's hard to tell what all was done. The changeset comment doesn't really explain much either.
I noticed because you changed Pioneer Courthouse Square & Director Park by replacing highway=pedestrian & area=yes with area:highway=pedestrian.
The wiki says:"Specifically, it is not the same as highway=pedestrian + area=yes, which represents a non-linear area, such as a square or plaza"
https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:area:highway=pedestrianI saw a few other issues. The speed limit was removed from Willamette Greenway. I haven't been there for a while, but I think there were actually speed signs. There is at least one road with deprecated parking tags removed without the new tags being added. I'm also curious why the level tag was removed from rooms in PSU buildings.
-
Comment from Spaghetti Monster🍝
Do you know if there's any consensus on this? Discussions? They seem functionally the same and area:highway is used across highway classes.
---
Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/134550384
-
Comment from tguen
I'm not aware of any discussion about it. I think highway=pedestrian & area=yes is an older method. It's used 230k times, about the same as area:highway=*, and area:highway=pedestrian is used only 7.4k times. FWIW Carto renders only highway+area.
I don't think it makes sense to have both and would support deprecation of highway+area, but I wouldn't retag existing features before it's officially done.
- 1160027481, v1
- 1160027482, v1
- 1160027483, v1
- 1160027484, v1
- 1160027485, v1
- 1160027486, v1
- Southwest Columbia Street (1160027487), v1
- 1160027488, v1
- 1160027489, v1
- 1160027490, v1
- 1160027491, v1
- 1160027492, v1
- 1160027493, v1
- 1160027494, v1
- 4684605, v26
- 5386628, v16
- 5386832, v21
- 5387111, v21
- 5387171, v17
- 5387232, v19
Relations (1-20 of 37)
- 1
- 2
- United States Highway 26 (Oregon Bicycle alternative) (532055), v238
- 1208289, v5
- 1416676, v5
- Schauff Circle (1641411), v4
- 1666862, v14
- 1700778, v3
- 1957146, v3
- 1957288, v11
- 2064359, v2
- Bus 35: Oregon City Transit Center => University of Portland (2662189), v106
- Bus 55: Portland => Raleigh Hills (2903402), v46
- Bus 45: Portland => Tigard Transit Center (2903406), v82
- Bus 6: Portland => Jantzen Beach (2904724), v76
- Bus 35: University of Portland => Oregon City Transit Center (4052670), v110
- Bus 58: Beaverton Transit Center => Portland (4071569), v46
- Bus 68: Portland => Marquam Hill (4087532), v28
- Bus 85: Rose Quarter Transit Center => Swan Island (4462209), v27
- Bus 85: Swan Island => Rose Quarter Transit Center (4462210), v23
- 5686314, v2
- Chevron (6191350), v7
- 10788582225, v1
- 10788582226, v1
- 10788582227, v1
- 10788582228, v1
- 10788582229, v1
- 10788582230, v1
- 10788582231, v1
- 10788582232, v1
- 10788582233, v1
- 10788582234, v1
- 10788582235, v1
- 10788582236, v1
- 10788582237, v1
- 10788582238, v1
- 10788582239, v1
- 10788582240, v1
- 10788582241, v1
- 10788582242, v1
- 10788582243, v1
- 27526572, v21
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |