Changeset: 30454936
Chasing the Bin Brook around Hardwick
Closed by Andy_W
Tags
build | 2.3-650-gad99430 |
---|---|
created_by | Potlatch 2 |
version | 2.3 |
Discussion
-
Comment from ACarlotti
There are a number of areas east of Hardwick that you have tagged as barrier=hedge and landuse=farmland. There are a couple of issues with this. Firstly, the use of a 'landuse' tag suggests that this way should be treated as an area, with the result that users of the data might incorrectly assume the whole field is a hedge (see e.g. the default renderer on openstreetmap.org at zoom levels 16 and above). Secondly, by tagging this on multiple adjoining fields (setting aside the area issue), you are effectively mapping the same hedge multiple times.
I'm wondering if you might be able to resolve these tagging issues - my suggestion would be to remove barrier=hedge from the fields and tag the hedges on separate non-overlapping (and probably shorter) ways.
I realise this issue partly predates your changeset (where the fields were tagged as fences instead of hedges). However, as the last person to have mapped these fields, and since I've never visited them myself, you are probably better placed than me to work out how to tag sections of the hedge appropriately (including knowing whether there should be any gaps in the hedges). -
Comment from Andy_W
I see the problem but am not convinced that I am the source ... not something I would knowingly do. As a start I have removed all the barrier tags added to landuse tags in this area. A check on the history of one of these problem areas suggests that user smb101 is the source : https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/337415057/history#map=16/52.2147/0.0271
-
Comment from ACarlotti
I agree that you aren't the original source; however, all the ones I'd noticed where ones where you'd changed the tag barrier=fence to barrier=hedge, without noticing the issue.
Ways (1-20 of 40)
- 1
- 2
- 25964816, v6
- 25964920, v6
- 255928567, v2
- 337412208, v4
- 337412214, v2
- 337412199, v2
- Bin Brook (340289462), v1
- Bin Brook (340289463), v1
- Bin Brook (25964916), v7
- 340289322, v2
- 340289716, v1
- Hardwick Road (4937672), v8
- Main Street (4937781), v6
- Main Street (32037012), v2
- Kings Road (4937793), v3
- 245516703, v2
- Cambridge Road (58670882), v2
- Bin Brook (340289463), v2
- 340289322, v1
- 340289323, v1
- 3475011246, v1
- 3475011247, v1
- 3475011248, v1
- 3475011249, v1
- 3475011250, v1
- 3475011251, v1
- 3475011252, v1
- 3475011253, v1
- 3475011254, v1
- 3445017437, v2
- 283252823, v2
- 283252824, v2
- 283252062, v2
- 2526966211, v2
- 3445017482, v2
- 2526966201, v2
- 3445017474, v2
- 283252822, v2
- 2616391003, v2
- 2616391025, v2
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |