Changeset: 68077053
Croatia
Closed by Vedran V
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (14760 en_GB) |
---|---|
source | Bing |
Discussion
-
Comment from aceman444
Hi, why are you adding these surface:grade=3 tags on roads in Croatia? There is no such approved tag in OSM and the tag was specifically abandoned. So what is the sense and meaning of it?
-
Comment from aceman444
You also claim to use Bing as the source of this data, which is suspicious as you can't see any quality/smoothness of a road from the Bing images in Croatia (they are not such high resolution). And they are even outdated. Some roads you tagged aren't even on Bing yet.
So what is the true source of your data? -
Comment from Vedran V
Hi,
as data source I use mix of my GPS traces, Digital Orthophoto i 50cm resolution from Croatian State Geodetic Administration, Esri Imagery and Mapbox Satellite. Why does it say "Bing Maps"? Well, I'm lazy to change description every time with data sources. That's why most of my changesets have also description "Croatia".About surface:grade tag. I've started using that tag 5-6 years ago to classify and with that tag I've described hundreds kms of roads. I'm using that tag to make better maps for local cycling clubs. Since "surface:grade" is not used anymore, and it doesn't interfere with "smoothness", I don't see big deal. I've also described road lightning with some tags that I have invented to make better models of map pollution.
-
Comment from aceman444
Please don't be lazy and put real source in each changeset and also put proper description. I do it with each changeset.
Otherwise if the source is lying and the description is junk, the changeset may not be taken seriously.It is fine in OSM to use your own tags, just that then all your work is only for you and useless for others. Especially when tags for the purpose already exist. It would be more useful for OSM if you used tags that others already agreed on. Thanks.
- Zelena Magistrala (676383276), v1
- Zelena Magistrala (676383277), v1
- Samoborska cesta (676383279), v1
- 13699500, v19
- 28052183, v13
- 28052185, v15
- Dubravica (29272871), v5
- Podsusedski most (29280877), v7
- 29909805, v24
- 29911417, v17
- 29911426, v18
- 29911920, v15
- 29913603, v11
- 29913606, v11
- 29913752, v11
- 29913753, v12
- 31361727, v11
- A3 (31361735), v19
- 31361749, v18
- 41242003, v31
Relations (7)
- Biciklistička staza Sljeme 1 (274592), v29
- Lokalna cesta 10021 (1287598), v16
- Lokalna cesta 10018 (1287887), v16
- Bus 119: Črnomerec - Podsused most (1758902), v24
- Črnomerec - Borčec (1762693), v17
- Bus 119: Podsused most - Črnomerec (2104537), v15
- N3 (3868765), v98
Nodes (1)
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |