OpenStreetMap

Exe19's Diary Comments

Diary Comments added by Exe19

Post When Comment
Road Curve Mapping Tips

I’d add a sub-point to “Keep Consistent Distance Between Nodes”: node spacing should be proportional to curvature:

  • If the curve is tight segments should be shorter,
  • if it’s gentle they should be longer and
  • if the segment is straight as laser beam then it should have no intermediate nodes unless something else requires it

That way the angular spacing is more consistent and we use nodes where they are the most useful.

Mapping a turbo roundabout

Thanks for responding back Peter.

I understand that if there’s physical separation then the carriageway is broken into segments and the OSM highways should branch away.

What spurred me into commenting was the scheme that you documented being used for a turbo where the only separators are the road markings ( Example here ). I think in such cases lanes-as-attributes would be more in line with existing road tagging.

Mapping a turbo roundabout

This proposed sheme seems to be a significant violation of “one highway segment per carriageway” rule.