Changeset: 35008086
update rondpoint serra walked it
Closed by wilda69
Tags
build | 2.4-12-g7158c69 |
---|---|
created_by | Potlatch 2 |
version | 2.4 |
Discussion
-
Comment from Stereo
Great :)
-
Comment from GerdP
please review:
the tag highway=demolished is rarely used.
Does it mean something like highway=construction or is it more a highway=abandoned?
See
http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:highway -
Comment from GerdP
or maybe highway=dismantled?
-
Comment from wilda69
dismantled is another tag that could be used. There is so much construction going on that very little is left. The point is that there are relations still attached to them which someone needs to update, so at the mom these nodes can not be deleted.
-
Comment from GerdP
okay. I try to reduce the different highway tags which mean something like "no highway", see also
http://gis.19327.n5.nabble.com/how-to-tag-a-highway-that-doesn-t-exist-tp5857111.html
If I got that right, most of the ways tagged demolished will not be rebuilt (at the same place), so I'd say highway=dismantled is better because it is used more often and it is documented in the wiki . -
Comment from Stereo
Hi! I have updated the relations Dan mentions, is there any reason we should still keep those demolished highways as highway=dismantled?
-
Comment from GerdP
I prefer to remove those ways, others want to keep some kind of history in OSM,
for example they build relations with names like "old interstate xyz " in the USA. -
Comment from wilda69
Many thanks for taking care of all the relations.
Difficult to judge if these roads have a historic value, but as I have not seen any plans what will happen to these after the tramcomplex has been built, it might be worth keeping them for a while. The new road looks very temporary, so there are bound to be more changes next year -
Comment from Stereo
This is the latest I've found:
http://images.newmedia.lu/rtl2008.lu/nt/p/2014/07/07/16/0740ac7672f01e8e9b3525f0bd47c948.jpeg
I think we should map what we can reliably check on the ground. Who knows what the future situation is really going to be like? I have just deleted the demolished ways.
- A 1 (377831444), v1
- Circuit de la Foire Internationale (377830290), v2
- 97829335, v4
- 377831514, v1
- 377831515, v1
- 9879893, v10
- 377830292, v2
- 377831570, v1
- P&R Kirchberg (8603565), v14
121642283, v5286901415, v3- P&R Kirchberg (8603565), v15
- 60856695, v7
- A 1 (27692784), v17
- Circuit de la Foire Internationale (292832459), v5
33695339, v9- 377831515, v2
- 376977521, v3
377830292, v3- Rue Hugo Gernsback (377832019), v1
Relations (11)
- VeloRoute SaarLorLux (20618), v669
- Piste cyclable d'Echternach (PC 2) (20351), v163
- AVL-1 - Hollerich/P&R Bouillon - Kirchberg/Luxexpo (555569), v75
- Regio DeLux (2032215), v78
- AVL-16 - Eurobus - Howald/Cité um Schlass - Aéroport (5402713), v3
- RGTR-125 - Hostert - Itzig (Eurobus) (1166451), v35
- 116 (1830581), v66
- RGTR-118 - Luxembourg - Trier (1151276), v122
- Regio DeLux (2032215), v79
- RGTR-125 - Hostert - Itzig (Eurobus) (1166451), v36
- 116 (1830581), v67
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |