Changeset: 37080630
making Chalkida - Lepoura and Lepoura - Karystos roads secondary as they lead to towns
Closed by JayCBR
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (8491 en) |
---|---|
source | knowledge |
Discussion
-
Comment from ika-chan! UK-USA
I disagree with making that national road secondary: Just because Karystos is merely a town doesn't mean that the Greek government considers the road to there unimportant.
-
Comment from nikospag
I disagree too. This road can't be a secondary road.
-
Comment from JayCBR
you guys..i thought you agreed on this scheme (roads connecting towns to be secondary)..instead of moving forward we go back?
ps: EO44 in fact ends in Lepoura -
Comment from nikospag
I've noticed a strange conflict in this system.We can not classify a road as secondary, that it has EO prefix at the same time, meaning that is characterized as National road by legal documents. Exceptions are National roads that have been replaced at a later time (after 1998).
Exception example is ΕΟ44β, which correctly is classified as secondary because has replaced by A11 at year 2007. -
Comment from ika-chan! UK-USA
What I was trying to say is usually (in many countries), classified roads determines the status, with very limited exceptions (e.g. totally impassable or no cars in Hydra). Then, because a lot of new roads in Greece are unclassified, connecting roads are tagged according to their overall condition between two points (e.g. settlements, junctions). it is never my intention that the classification changes every time the layout changes: that just makes the whole thing confusing for the navigation systems that depend on us.
nikospag, I'd like to point out that we should not spread National roads over more than two classes, to reduce confusion. What is currently mapped as ΕΟ44β is actually Boeotia ΕΠ34 (the latest data for the two units is from 1955), while the A11 follows the ΕΟ44β.
-
Comment from nikospag
This conversation must be transferred to the forum. I will open a topic and i will copy-paste all comments from here
- 222614541, v2
- 207503347, v5
- 207288415, v3
- 130777466, v4
- 211167574, v2
- 207707635, v4
- 84678382, v12
- 84678420, v5
- 232070105, v3
- 226622620, v2
- 226624005, v2
- 207519476, v6
- 207518216, v6
- 207289264, v10
- 207519478, v7
- 207289291, v4
- 372181518, v2
- 207503346, v4
- 32127237, v4
- 207504209, v3
Relations (1)
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |