Changeset: 37496101
Bavaria: survey details in and around MPIO Seewiesen
Closed by mcld
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (8800 en_GB) |
---|---|
source | survey |
Discussion
-
Comment from Polarbear
Hallo, ich frage mich ob man das ornithologische Max-Planck-Institut als Universität taggen sollte, laut Webseite fliegen dort allenfalls Doktoranden herum. landuse=residential scheint mir auch fraglich, wohnt dort jemand?
-
Comment from mcld
Hi. I am not German so I don't know what the best tagging for a Max-Planck-Institut is. It teaches PhDs but I think it is not officially a university?
Also you are right, it is not landuse=residential. This should be changed. (People DO live there, but only in the guesthouse.)
(I didn't change those tags myself, but it'd be good to tag it right!)
-
Comment from mcld
landuse=institutional?
-
Comment from Polarbear
No that is not established, controversial and draft only. landuse=commercial is more common for such sites. A few Guesthouses are a minor use which should not determine the tag.
It is certainly not a university. I read a bit in the wiki and there is amenity=research_institute, and office=research for such a facility.
-
Comment from mcld
I like amenity=research_institute, and would support tagging it that way, although I notice it's even less established than landuse=institutional !
-
Comment from Polarbear
There might be less research institutes than what is controversially subsumed under that landuse tag, which might be popular with a few mappers. 266 vs. 117 should not guide the decision here.
landuse=commercial puts the landuse into an established category, and amenity=research_institute describes it further. office=research can be put on the office buildings.
-
Comment from mcld
I'm not happy with landuse=commercial, when the institute is not commercial: it is state-funded. It is _much_ stranger in my opinion to tag the site as if it was commercial than if it was a university. It implies the wrong affordances. The rest I am OK with.
-
Comment from Polarbear
landuse does not reflect where the funding for an amenity within the land comes from.
-
Comment from mcld
No, but the MPIO does not fit the meaning of landuse=commercial, neither in my commonsense understanding, nor the wiki description: "Use tag landuse=commercial to delineate areas of land used for commercial purposes." This land is NOT used for commercial purposes, so I recommend we do not use the tag.
-
Comment from Polarbear
I understand your arguments. We may better continue on the tagging list. There was a proposal for landuse=civic, which later drifted into civic_admin only.
- 400553922, v1
- 400553923, v1
- 400553924, v1
- 400553925, v1
- 400553926, v1
- 400553927, v1
- Eberhard-Gwinner-Straße (400553928), v1
- 400553929, v1
- 400553930, v1
- 400553931, v1
- 400553932, v1
- 400553933, v1
- 400553934, v1
- 400553935, v1
- 400553936, v1
- 400553937, v1
- 400553938, v1
- 400553939, v1
- 400553940, v1
- 400553941, v1
Relations (2)
- RegionalBus 951: Herrsching S-Bahn => Starnberg Nord (3521384), v19
- RegionalBus 951: Starnberg Nord => Herrsching S-Bahn (1761404), v35
- Seewiesen (4031034162), v1
- Seewiesen (4031034163), v1
- 4031034164, v1
- 4031034165, v1
- 4031034166, v1
- 4031034167, v1
- 4031034168, v1
- 4031034169, v1
- 4031034170, v1
- 4031034171, v1
- 4031034172, v1
- 4031034173, v1
- 4031034174, v1
- 4031034175, v1
- 4031034176, v1
- 4031034177, v1
- 4031034178, v1
- 4031034179, v1
- 4031034180, v1
- 4031034181, v1
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |