Changeset: 39252488
TIGER cleanup
Closed by jonathanpatt
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (9979 en) |
---|---|
source | Bing |
Discussion
-
Comment from stevea
About your comment "changed tags for proper rendering." This is just plain wrong, and is blatant "coding for the renderer." We have been down this road before, and many times. I tire of this edit war, and it must stop.
We need to establish a truce with GDMBR. GDMBR is NOT an ncn, as it crosses an international boundary. I have changed it to icn because it does, and this was even agreed to by a current or former member of OSM's Data Working Group (for lack of a better analogy, we can think of the DWG as OSM's "data police").
I also saw that you cloned (duplicated) the relation and tagged it route=mtb, which I believe and hereby assert is the ultimately correct solution. I have also heard from others (more international OSM volunteers outside of the USA) that they find the solution of calling ANY mountain bike route either an ncn or an icn as completely wrong: that is not done anywhere else in the world, and so we should not do it here in the USA (and/or Canada).
So, I propose we delete http://www.osm.org/relation/3161159 (GDMBR tagged with network=ncn) and we keep http://www.osm.org/relation/6073693 (GDMBR tagged with route=mtb).
I will not tolerate a GDMBR relation with either network=icn or especially network=ncn simply because you find it convenient that it renderers where-ever you like to see it rendered. That is not how OSM works.
Ways (4)
Relations (3)
- 603 (1492662), v3
- Great Divide Mountain Bike Route (3161159), v416
- Great Divide Mountain Bike Route (6073693), v5
- 4179419289, v1
- 4179419290, v1
- 4179419291, v1
- 4179419292, v1
- 4179419293, v1
- 4179419294, v1
- 4179419295, v1
- 4179419296, v1
- 4179419297, v1
- 4179419298, v1
- 4179419299, v1
- 4179419300, v1
- 4179419301, v1
- 4179419302, v1
- 4179419303, v1
- 4179419304, v1
- 141141680, v3
- 141339977, v3
- 141437860, v3
- 141448801, v4
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |