Changeset: 39359610
modified parking, addes highway
Closed by 4b696d
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (10168 de) |
---|---|
source | Bing |
Discussion
-
Comment from ccamara
I've seen you have displaced the parking and detached it from "plaça dels estudis" way, which is the way used to get into it. Is there any reason why the previous position was wrong and makes this change necessary?
-
Comment from 4b696d
I found out that there was no connection between the stairs (northwest of the parking) and the Carrer de Vic. I added that one.
The way of a highway should be in the middle of it. If you connect an area to such a way it would mean that the area would end only in the middle of this way. This is not true. Same applies to the playground next to it.
You don't attach the buildings to the street - why should you attach the parking? When I look at the parking right now, I realize that in the south it includes some kind of sidewalk. I made a mistake at this point. -
Comment from ccamara
"I found out that there was no connection between the stairs (northwest of the parking) and the Carrer de Vic. I added that oe." -> You're right, there is a footway connecting both (not a path).
"You don't attach the buildings to the street - why should you attach the parking?" I see your point, but I am not sure I understand your previous reasoning nor I share the conclusion (but I'm somewhat newbie to it, so that's why I am asking).
At this poing the parking area is unconnected to the street, which is not right according to reality. One way to connect it would be to add a service way connecting "Plaça dels Estudis" street to the parking area, but whereas that would be right from a OSM logic, it would not fit reality, as there is no such service way. For this reason I decided to connect both the highway and the area from its side, as that's how it works in reality (there is a lowered kerb that allows cars' entry along the way, not just from one point.
What do you think now? Do you still think that having unconnected way/parking is better than the previous one? (I do, admit though that the playground shouldn't be connected, as you say)
-
Comment from 4b696d
There is no need to connect the parking itself. As you say, use highway= service and service=parking asile to draw the ways inside the parking. Connect these directly to the road.
On the Bing image I cannot identify any parking spots, but I guess that there is a system that you might know.
As for the path: If you think footway would be more adequate simply correct it. :-)
Ways (4)
Nodes (15)
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |