Changeset: 43775555
Updating Wikidata IDs from corresponding Wikipedia tags
Closed by nyuriks
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (11223 en) |
---|
Discussion
-
Comment from woodpeck
You seem to be using an automated process to match Wikidata tags to exisitng OSM entries. This is a mechanical edit that requires prior discussion and agreement in the community. See https://forum.openstreetmap.org/viewtopic.php?pid=618618
-
Comment from nyuriks
@woodpeck, thanks for the heads up! I was using the JOSM's Wikipedia plugin - "Fetch Wikidata IDs" command to lookup IDs for rels and ways which had Wikipedia tag already. In the process I also uncovered a number of plugin bugs, some of which are now fixed. The process was not automated - rather I would pull an area I was interested in using a query relation["wikipedia"]["wikidata"!~".*"]["boundary"]({{bbox}}); add WD tags, and upload just the WD changes. In any case, I will slow down on changes until the community agrees, and until the JOSM plugin resolves the pending bugs.
-
Comment from woodpeck
Yeah, it is ok (even desirable) to add wikidata plugins to an individual object that you are looking at and that you have knowledge about, but it is not ok to simply mark everything and have the plugin slap on wikidata tags wholesale - that would then count as a mechanical edit.
-
Comment from nyuriks
Understood, I will mostly work on high level objects (admin level <= 6) - those are easy to check, and provide the most interest to me.
-
Comment from nyuriks
P.S. posted my thoughts at https://forum.openstreetmap.org/viewtopic.php?pid=618646#p618646
-
Comment from woodpeck
I have read your forum entry, and what you are doing there (automatically adding Wikidata IDs with a JOSM plugin) is clearly a mechanical edit. You should not be doing that kind of editing across the globe without involving the local community and discussing your approach on a suitable mailing list, or the entirety of your edits is liable to be reverted for violating the mechanical edit procedures.
-
Comment from nyuriks
Woodpeck, I have already stopped changing any objects except the admin levels regions 1-6, and even those I have greatly slowed down, and began reviewing most of the auto-resolved wikidata IDs. I will cease further automodifications, and instead concentrate on getting wikidata tags quality review for the admin levels.
- Краснопольский район (70602), v13
- Костюковичский район (70604), v19
- Климовичский район (70610), v22
- Кричевский район (70614), v18
- Мстиславский район (70616), v18
- Кашинский район (570637), v63
- Жарковский район (910734), v19
- Западнодвинский район (910735), v20
- Оленинский район (930884), v15
- Грязинский район (1113196), v42
- Воловский район (1113569), v29
- Тербунский район (1113578), v24
- Добринский район (1113581), v21
- Липецкий район (1113711), v35
- Усманский район (1113768), v35
- Задонский район (1114910), v29
- Хлевенский район (1114911), v23
- Елецкий район (1116513), v26
- Долгоруковский район (1116708), v22
- Измалковский район (1116714), v22
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |