Changeset: 45060415
Wiesloch: Leimbach Park + Dremmelwald + AVR
Closed by sladen
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (10526 en_GB) |
---|---|
source | Survey 201701 + Bing |
Discussion
-
Comment from mapper999
Could you have a look at http://keepright.ipax.at/report_map.php?schema=94&error=81426259&zoom=17&lat=49.29215&lon=8.66712&layers=B0T&ch=0%2C30%2C40%2C50%2C70%2C90%2C100%2C120%2C130%2C150%2C160%2C180%2C191%2C192%2C193%2C194%2C195%2C196%2C197%2C198%2C201%2C202%2C203%2C204%2C205%2C206%2C207%2C208%2C210%2C220%2C231%2C232%2C270%2C281%2C282%2C283%2C284%2C291%2C292%2C293%2C311%2C312%2C313%2C350%2C380%2C411%2C412&show_ign=1&show_tmpign=1 please? You left some untagged ways and not properly connected junctions.
-
Comment from sladen
…Marked a large number of false positive. The untagged ways are template lines (circles and parallel lines use for constructions of arcs and outlines); and where, once created it makes sense to keep these in the map to all re-rectifying.
-
Comment from tyr_asd
sorry, I don't get it. Why would it make sense to keep your "templates" in the DB? Couldn't you just store them in a local .osm file on your PC, if you need them again at some point in the future?
-
Comment from sladen
@tyr_asd: why would I necessary be the person doing the next edit? The intent behind OSM is to enable access and equal ability-to-contribute by all.
Storing some work offline, but other work online creates an imbalance between contributors. A similiar situation can occur when GPS traces were used, but are not available: therefore OSM has a mechanism for uploading GPS traces, which can then be accessed by all, equally.
-
Comment from tyr_asd
Hmm. Yes, but if I were the next editor, I wouldn't know how to use your data. In fact, it would possibly even hinder any further editing: for example, I wouldn't know if I can remove these lines that don't correspond to any actual feature on the ground or not.
While I partially understand the motivation behind keeping the two circles (e.g. http://www.openstreetmap.org/way/464954584)*, for me it is totally unclear what the remaining lines are good for. For example: http://www.openstreetmap.org/way/465011450 or http://www.openstreetmap.org/way/464954580 – can you explain why we need those? If yes: at least, please add a note tag explaining how they are intended to be used by your fellow mappers.
My point is that if only you know how to use it, that data is indistinguishable from garbage for everyone else. You can't compare that to OSM's GPS traces, where the functionality and intended usage is well documented. Thanks for understanding. :)
* but even those could be redrawn very quickly by the next mapper in case they want to adjust the tracks while keeping the perfect round shape.
-
Comment from mapper999
I generally don't have a problem with template lines, but please give them at least a note tag so that other mappers know how to use them and they don't show up in QA tools. Sometimes it also helps to use noexit=yes, when ways are not connected.
-
Comment from sladen
@tyr_asd, 456011450 has been tagged with an additional 'note='; and 464954580 has been deleted. Thank you for highlighting these. Imagery, photographs, GPS traces, surveys, measurements, and derived template lines all form a basis for cartography. Ever little helps, and any individual cartographer can only work from the selection they have before them. With OSM the aim is to share, to allow equal contribution by all.
@mapper999: Yes, definitely!
-
Comment from tyr_asd
Thanks @sladen!
Ways (1-20 of 26)
- 1
- 2
- 465007904, v1
- 405263315, v2
- 405265866, v5
- Staatsbahnhofstraße (5078611), v7
- 60774700, v5
405265865, v3- 465011450, v1
- 465011451, v1
- 465011452, v1
- 465011453, v1
- 403786107, v5
- 403787379, v5
- 464961088, v2
400414717, v8403787377, v2405265866, v6- Staatsbahnhofstraße (465012775), v1
- Staatsbahnhofstraße (5078611), v8
- 403786097, v3
- 465014531, v1
Relations (2)
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |