Changeset: 48834097
landuse=farm retagged
Closed by kreuzschnabel
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (12039 de) |
---|---|
source | Bing |
Discussion
-
Comment from kreuzschnabel
These were the last landuse=farm on the British Isles, so please don’t add new ones :-) And just in time we were, the new carto revision (which will not render landuse=farm any more) seems to have been switched active a few hours later.
-
Comment from trigpoint
It was never a pressing issue, farm/farmland is of dubious values consiting of vast areas armchaired by crayonists. It.adds very little value to those of us using OSM in rural areas.
Many areas close to me were poorly drawn with connections to roads/rivers (not riverbank) and I had left them until I had time to map those areas properly. However you simply armchaired them without considering if they actually add anything. -
Comment from kreuzschnabel
I agree that landuse=farmland is of pretty little use (moreover, it’s not clearly defined from landuse=meadow, so there are areas already where these two collide). landuse=farmyard, on the other hand, is of higher value for the walker or bicyclist, and I wouldn’t really like to miss them (or even their names) in the maps (and quite a lot of the farmyard elements edited by me bear names). This here effort was rather a sporting one, of course, and I do apologize for not having spent my time on more pressing issues ;-) And please don’t let you keep from mapping those areas more carefully as I just added four letters to the landuse=* value.
-
Comment from trigpoint
I would agree farmyard is far more important than farmland itself. It is afterall the default state of non urban areas. It is a big shame that meadow has been so badly misused, it should be a rare but useful tag. Most.is simply pasture.
If we are going to map farmland we should be doing it at a much finer level than we have so far. At a field by field level with farmland=arable/pasture.
As a countryside user/mapper the most useful features.are the barriers. Hence I tend to map hedges/fences/stiles/gates and ignore landuse.
Well enough of my moaning, have fun mapping.
Cheers Phil -
Comment from SomeoneElse
Hi kreuzschnabel,
This looks very much like a mechanical edit. Have you ever actually visited e.g.
https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/2876566751/history to see if it deserves any sort of "place" tag?
Best Regards,
Andy Townsend, on behalf of OSM's Data Working Group.
- 127429908, v2
- 127429909, v2
- 127429911, v2
- 127429912, v2
- 258336752, v6
- 258356368, v4
- 259431230, v2
- 259431231, v2
- 259431233, v2
- 259431235, v2
- 259431236, v4
- 259431237, v2
- 259435178, v2
- 259435179, v2
- 259435180, v2
- 259435181, v2
- 259435182, v2
- 259435188, v2
- 259435189, v2
- 259435190, v3
Nodes (1-20 of 27)
- 1
- 2
- Broad Oak Farm (271045), v3
- Fleetwater House (271047), v3
- Grove Farm (271082), v3
- Robins Bush Farm (271085), v3
- Worthys Farmhouse (271422), v3
- Gambledown House (1803465), v3
- Conygree Farm (272024734), v2
- Harrow Farm (360910753), v2
- 433278235, v2
- Starveall Farm (579829059), v2
- Kingswood Farm (579829066), v2
- Wood Farm (579829075), v2
- Lodge Farm (579829092), v2
- Bevis Farm (579829136), v2
- Lee's Rest (579829152), v2
- New Zealand Farm (688067723), v2
- Friars Farm (1967307973), v2
- Lower Farm (1967326065), v2
- Pinnocks Farm (1967326067), v2
- Park Farm (1967326069), v2
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |