Changeset: 49398040
Update in Nice
Closed by miniwark
Tags
created_by | iD 2.2.1 |
---|---|
host | http://www.openstreetmap.org/edit |
imagery_used | Bing aerial imagery |
locale | fr |
Discussion
-
Comment from aceman444
Hi, I've seen you have changed some highway=pedestrian areas into place=square. But that is not the same and place=square does not imply highway=pedestrian. So I have put some of the highway=pedestrian tags back.
-
Comment from miniwark
Hi aceman,
well... this areas are actually notable Squares in the city !
They are not just pedestrian areas.
See : https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:place%3DsquareThe Wiki says than squares include everything, including the pedestrian parts...
- Garibaldi Place have many trees, a big fontain/sculpture, a road and the tramway.
- Massena place is also traversed by the tramway and a big street (felix Faure). There is also a big fontain/scultpure, and the small semi-circle street in the south are also part of it (same name).Also https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:highway%3Dpedestrian#Plazas
Say than the square tag is a alternative for "plazzas"I do not revert myself, but i find the square tag more relevant for this
big places than the semi-anonymous pedestrian+are tags. -
Comment from aceman444
Hi, I totally agree with you and I have seen those wiki pages and understand the concept of place=square. I have left the place=square tags on the areas. I just say, that if you just changed highway=pedestrian into place=square you have lost the information the area is a pedestrian are an can be walked on by pedestrians and is also not visible to routing engines. So If you change to place=square and then micromap and split the area into more parts depending on if they are pedestrian areas or something else (a large fountain as you say), then that would be great and go on. But that wasn't done. I just saw that pedestrian areas got lost. So I think I put back the highway=pedestrian on some squares that really looked like (on bing) just a big pedestrian area. Thanks.
- 499311182, v1
- 499311184, v1
- 499311186, v1
- 499311187, v1
- 499311188, v1
- 499311189, v1
- 499311190, v1
- 499311191, v1
- 499311192, v1
- 499311193, v1
- 499311194, v1
- 499311195, v1
- Esplanade de la Bourgada (193676945), v5
- Parvis de l'Église du Voeu (193676946), v4
- 140188180, v2
- Placette Père Marie-Joseph Steve (37747779), v4
- Centre catholique universitaire (143921068), v3
- 243899293, v5
- Avenue Saint-Jean-Baptiste (146740149), v5
- Avenue Felix Faure (23707583), v16
- 4810013346, v2
- 2779377494, v2
- 1878323289, v3
- 966638552, v4
- 2142865757, v2
- 456944793, v4
- 1878323213, v2
- 456944794, v4
- 24342502, v8
- 456944811, v4
- 1878323274, v2
- 1019157602, v3
- 2344779310, v3
- 22447552, v6
- 24665533, v7
- 1878323211, v2
- 1878323231, v2
- 4905974683, v1
- 4905974684, v1
- 4905974685, v1
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |