Changeset: 52731864
Žagarės antrasis piliakalnis: corrected Wikidata/Wikipedia tags (was referring to disambiguation page)
Closed by kartonage
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (12921 en) |
---|
Discussion
-
Comment from Tomas Straupis
Change reverted.
Please do not change wikipedia tags without local knowledge according to automatically added incorrect wikidata tags.
Wikidata tag removed as well so that other people do not try to "autofix" without doing actual work. -
Comment from kartonage
To give you my thought process with this one:
While I understand that you have local knowledge here, the original Wikidata added in changeset #48873625 by rmikke (the previous changeset) have their origin in the wikipedia-tag you added initially.
In general if there is a specific page for that object it is preferable to use that specific entry for both wikipedia and wikidata instead of the disambiguation page, which usually contains a handful of entirely different meanings or is unspecific.
A lot of times wikidata=* has been added that point to these disambiguation pages. In most cases with a little bit of research (which I do) one can easily point ot the specific page on wikipedia. Which is an improvement.In this case I had to read into it a bit with help of translations. To my best knowledge I chose the one that fit the place and description. If that was wrong, apologies. While the disambiguation page for this site only contains two pages of roughly the same topic and therefor is fairly specific alread, it still could be linked to the exact object in my opinion. But I will leave that up to you.
Cheers
-
Comment from Tomas Straupis
We're fixing wikipedia tags, coordinates (in OSM, Wikipedia and other local sources) without using wikidata. There are some other open sources for hillforts/heritage in Lithuania which I'm using.
In this case you've added a link to wikipedia page "Hillfort X 2" for an object which has a name of "Hillfort X 1". Which clearly shows a problem (1 != 2). -
Comment from Tomas Straupis
Time for this hillfort data to be fixed will come soon, but not today :-)
-
Comment from kartonage
I understand and agree, thanks for the clarification Tomas!
Nodes (1)
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |