Changeset: 53753685
add name:sr to place
Closed by Serbian OSM Lint bot
Tags
created_by | Sophox 0.5 |
---|---|
imagery_used | OpenStreetMap (Standard) |
task_id | undefined |
Discussion
-
Comment from Nakaner
Hi,
I have told you recently in changeset comments and via personal messages that your mechanical edits outside Serbia must be discussed on the Talk mailing list. Instead, you just uploaded another mechanical edit. As you can read on the Talk mailing list, Sophox is seen as a tool for mechanical edits.
What is the source of this changeset? How did you create the Serbian names?
Please refrain from further use of Sophox.
Best regards
Michael
-
Comment from Nakaner
just for reference for other readers: https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/53165375
-
Comment from Branko Kokanovic
So, in reference you are mentioning, I was adding name:sr-Latn which is not allowed outside of Serbia (and doesn't make sense). In this changeset, I was just adding local names (same as other languages are doing, and especially troublesome for non-native readers of Japanese, even when we follow https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Names#Avoid_transliteration). This is *not* bot doing it, this is person doing this, using Sophox for help, here is reference: https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Talk:Serbia/Sophox (pointers to discussion where other person was asking about it). So, to conclude - 1) these are not mechanical edits, 2) this are not some kind of edit types that are new to OSM, 3) I am not running Sophox as a tool, but as a helper for mapping manually, 4) I gave references. Hope this makes sense
-
Comment from Nakaner
Hi Branko,
that someone else has done something bad is not a justification for you to do the same bad thing.
It is not troublesome for people who cannot read Japanese because data users can use transliteration libraries. The German OSM Carto style is a great example.
What are the sources of your changeset?
Best regards
Michael
PS I have not asked the DWG to do anything.
-
Comment from woodpeck_repair
This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changeset 53785191 where the changeset comment is: revert undiscussed mechanical edits - mostly automated name:sr adding, is_in adding, and changes to wiki link - by user 'Serbian OSM Lint bot
Relations (15)
- 流山市 (2679928), v12
- 柏市 (2679925), v15
- 高崎市 (3555552), v40
- 前橋市 (3563845), v23
- 土浦市 (2682900), v7
- 日立市 (2682911), v9
- 盛岡市 (963784), v12
- 我孫子市 (2679918), v11
- 水戸市 (2682914), v8
- 奥州市 (963782), v13
- 越谷市 (1768402), v16
- 野田市 (2679940), v12
- ひたちなか市 (2682892), v11
- 取手市 (2682898), v8
- 春日部市 (1768400), v16
- 越谷市 (864255939), v7
- 流山市 (2098183365), v7
- 柏市 (2098183362), v6
- 我孫子市 (2098146404), v6
- 春日部市 (864248665), v9
- 鴻巣市 (820097446), v8
- 古河市 (1419245750), v8
- 佐野市 (1108891363), v10
- 伊勢崎市 (1068823679), v12
- 取手市 (1699286306), v10
- 野田市 (2115840215), v6
- 桐生市 (1068823646), v14
- 前橋市 (574841107), v21
- 水戸市 (736355846), v11
- 深谷市 (820591253), v10
- 太田市 (1068823657), v10
- 小山市 (1108891371), v8
- 足利市 (1108891308), v11
- 高崎市 (1068823649), v18
- つくば市 (768273008), v8
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |