Changeset: 53998264
Vandalism, Copy name from google maps. The name of the street is Lech Kaczyński source https://ipn.gov.pl/pl/aktualnosci/polityka/zmiany-nazw-ulic/nazwy-ulic/nazwy-do-zmiany/36804,ul-Armii-Ludowej.html
Closed by deleted
Tags
Discussion
-
Comment from wuc_rulez
This is actually incorrect. The article cites that the name of the street **should be** changed. The actual name of the street is "Aleja Armii Ludowej". Until the name if officially changed it should stay under the old name.
-
Comment from user_4493657
The name is official and valid source: http://edziennik.mazowieckie.pl/WDU_W/2017/10139/akt.pdf
-
Comment from wuc_rulez
Still not true. This document states that the President of Warsaw is ordered to change the name of street from "Al. Armii Ludowej" to "Lecha Kaczyńskiego". The actual name of the street is still unchanged - "Al. Armii Ludowej". Forcing name change before the actual change takes place is not only incorrect but also confuses users of OpenStreetMaps. We should only change names of the streets once they are executed.
-
Comment from user_4493657
The name Lecha Kaczyńskiego is official and valid. old name Al. Armii Ludowej ist in old_name also some time valid and searchable for navi.
If the street name will officially again changed to another, it will be officially announced in edziennik.mazowieckie.pl -
Comment from wuc_rulez
Repeating same arguments will not allow us to progress with the discussion. I believe we need external reviewer help. The official addresses and name plates on the street still state "Al. Armii Ludowej". Until that is changed we should not change the name to the "future" one.
-
Comment from Natsuyasumi
Well, the document http://edziennik.mazowieckie.pl/WDU_W/2017/10139/akt.pdf states that it is, in fact, changed to "Lecha Kaczyńskiego". The official map of Warsaw (http://www.mapa.um.warszawa.pl/mapaApp1/mapa?service=fast_mapa) also states it is called "Lecha Kaczyńskiego".
But, the definition from OSM wiki of key: name is "The common default name. (Note: For disputed areas, please use the name as displayed on, e.g., street signs for the name tag. [...])", and it's impossible to change all of the street signs within few days of annoucing the change.
I rockon to leave it as "Aleja Armii Ludowej" (and put "Lecha Kaczyńskiego" under alt_name/official_name), and change it when most of the signs are changed to "Lecha Kaczyńskiego".
- Lecha Kaczyńskiego (4898199), v31
- Lecha Kaczyńskiego (4898200), v34
- Lecha Kaczyńskiego (4898201), v25
- Lecha Kaczyńskiego (4898203), v30
- Lecha Kaczyńskiego (4898206), v17
- Lecha Kaczyńskiego (4898216), v19
- Lecha Kaczyńskiego (4898217), v18
- Lecha Kaczyńskiego (4898218), v22
- Lecha Kaczyńskiego (4898221), v27
- Lecha Kaczyńskiego (4898223), v23
- Lecha Kaczyńskiego (4898228), v27
- Lecha Kaczyńskiego (4898229), v31
- Lecha Kaczyńskiego (4902478), v23
- Lecha Kaczyńskiego (4902479), v35
- Lecha Kaczyńskiego (4902480), v25
- Lecha Kaczyńskiego (4907787), v28
- Lecha Kaczyńskiego (4907791), v36
- Lecha Kaczyńskiego (4949276), v24
- Lecha Kaczyńskiego (4949277), v25
- Lecha Kaczyńskiego (4949278), v34
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |