Changeset: 55302140
Added port tag, names and type.
Closed by Legolash2oLiam
Tags
changesets_count | 787 |
---|---|
created_by | iD 2.5.1 |
host | https://www.openstreetmap.org/edit |
imagery_used | Bing aerial imagery |
locale | en-GB |
Discussion
-
Comment from chillly
This seems an odd edit. Why have you added Hull Port as a locality in the middle of a named dock? AFAIK 'Hull Port' does not exist. What are you trying to do with this edit?
-
Comment from Legolash2oLiam
I've moved it to a better place (more centre and on land). I think it should be on the boundary but others had done a node, so a followed that pattern.
Rather than displaying all the docks on my visualisation, I'd rather just have the port itself.
This particular port is owned by ABP (Associated British Ports) and it receives RoRo (Ferries, Cars, Trucks) and LoLo traffic (Containers).
-
Comment from Legolash2oLiam
I also fixed its name to 'The Port of Hull' to match literature based on it.
-
Comment from chillly
Hmmm, this still doesn't seem very good. 'The Port of Hull' is a better name, but it's not a locality IMHO - it's a port. Adding stuff in an arbitrary place with a dubious tag so it appears on your own render is not a great way of editing. Maybe there's a seamark tag for a port that might be better.
-
Comment from Legolash2oLiam
It wasn't just for my own visualisation, there's other ways I can do that. I'd rather share when I can; unless it's confidential.
I half agree with the 'arbitrary' part but I fully agree with you on the 'locality' tag, as it didn't seem right. As I said before I'd rather have done the boundary (which appears how it's documented), but last night someone had previously used a node and I wrongly assumed that was the method. I don't mind fixing it. Overall it's good that you pointed it out and it's a good learning experience. I prefer just to stick to rail lol.
Nodes (20)
- Heysham Port (5329921876), v1
- Goole Dock (5329921877), v1
- Hull Port (5329921878), v1
- Killingholme Port (5329921879), v1
- Immingham Port (5329921880), v1
- Grimsby Port (5329921881), v1
- 291455105, v5
- 1704847002, v2
- 291455098, v5
- 1390288148, v3
- 1390288145, v4
- 1390288138, v4
- 1390288146, v5
- 1704847001, v2
- 1704846999, v2
- 1704847000, v2
- Liverpool Port (5329890964), v2
- Mostyn Dock (1157496478), v4
- Holyhead Port (5329890962), v2
- Birkenhead Port (5329890963), v2
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |