Changeset: 56600277
Cleanup variations of: shop=gift
Closed by HubMiner
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (13367 en) |
---|
Discussion
-
Comment from trigpoint
Hi, this appears to be an undiscussed mechanical edit. Did you follow the procedure detailed in https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Automated_Edits_code_of_conduct and if so where was it discussed?
In my experience the two are different and this type of tag homogenising just makes for a bland map.
-
Comment from HubMiner
Hello, at first I cleaned up different misspells of souvenir, and I got editor warning that "shop=souvenir" is an obsolete value and should not be used.
I saw the same mentioned on "gift" wiki, confirming that "gift" covers both:
https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag%3Ashop%3DgiftI assumed these two address the discussion needs.
Let me know if you'd prefer to undo the change.
Regards
-
Comment from trigpoint
Hi, thank you for your reply. I do believe that this change should be undone.
It does need discussion, I and other mappers do consider these to be different
things, or at least require subtagging.
Maybe souvenir should be a subtag of gift, but simply removing that important piece of information means that surveyed information is lost.On the discussion page https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Talk:Tag:shop%3Dgift a very good comment has been added "For me, a souvenir shop is where you stop by far away from home to take something along for you, a gift shop is where you get in on the way to the birthday party you forgot about. They are two quite distinct concepts."
It also says on the wiki page "Automated edits are strongly discouraged unless you really know what you are doing!"
The wiki is supposed to document how mappers, map it should not be taken as an instruction on how to map or what is right or wrong.
Cheers Phil
-
Comment from HubMiner
I reverted the changeset; thanks.
Ways (18)
- 33175560, v3
- Museumsshop Remise (58781927), v4
- Berlin Tourist Info (60203543), v16
- Ametyst (104517153), v3
- 129911622, v2
- 148159450, v3
- El Bazar (173819500), v3
- Souvenirshop Cowboy (173819528), v3
- 183718067, v3
- 221049384, v2
- 221049445, v2
- 221049446, v2
- The Aviation Shop (233759664), v3
- 283106330, v4
- 283107235, v4
- 283107269, v4
- Stadium Store (487760322), v5
- PANNart (512776507), v6
- 304199330, v4
- 318979778, v4
- Slottsbutik (447953919), v4
- 692966683, v3
- Alibaba (989943251), v3
- Jussarö vierassatama (1113869600), v4
- Darsser Schatztruhe (1317422447), v3
- Seifenland (1338305757), v3
- Amatu istaba (1367506781), v3
- 1585253486, v2
- 1650227361, v2
- 1826003941, v2
- 1841857831, v2
- Fantasy Shop (1845794149), v3
- Antique Book Shop (2352386780), v3
- 2366293550, v3
- Info-Hus (2395174733), v3
- 2431517404, v2
- 2459739110, v3
- El Bastardo (2696449845), v3
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |