Changeset: 59194818
Mountain passes from Rusian mountenering club Westra
Closed by Alexheel
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (13576 ru) |
---|---|
source | OSM Wiki, http://westra.ru/passes/, Tunderforest, Bing |
Discussion
-
Comment from dikkeknodel
Hi Alexheel,
If I understand correctly, you added the Russian name to mountain passes in Switzerland, Austria, Italy and France. I also see you added the tags rtsa_scale and westra_ref. I notice you give the website of Westra as source for these edits. I can't read Russian, but assume Westra is the Russian Mountaineering association, or similar. Their website mentions a (c) copyright symbol, so I see a potential issue here with if the data is allowed in OSM.
About the tags you added, I don't see anything on wiki.openstreetmap.org about these tags. For these tags to be relevant to all users, not only insiders, it is relevant to make a proposal for these tags on the wiki and discuss about it in my opinion. Now most people won't have a clue what is means and how to use them.Could you please address these two concerns?
Keep up the happy mapping :-)
Cheers from Switzerland,
dikkeknodel -
Comment from Alexheel
Hi! Thanks, that you looking after mountain areas in OSM. In many regions in Asia were i have mapped, nobody has no interest to correct mapping.
1. Westra gave approval to use theirs mountain passes list many years ago on forum russian osm forum and on their own forum. I am only the first, who uploaded their passes in Alps. This information is insignificant, and you can delete it if want.
2. about rtsa_scale: https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:rtsa_scale.There are 7801 notes with this tag and it is wery useful information to russian mountaineer. If you don't want to see it in Alps - delete it.
westra_ref: this number in values in this tag is the number in http://westra.ru/passes/Passes/ (example:westra_ref=11637 is a http://westra.ru/passes/Passes/11637).I doh't invented that tag (westra_ref=*) ,it was used before me, and i agree, that it is don't comfortably. I try to change that in osm tag source=* or website=*
Alexheel -
Comment from dikkeknodel
Hi Alexheel,
Thanks for getting back on this topic. I'm not sure why I couldn't find the rtsa_scale on the wiki, since it's clearly there. Must be a typo on my side. Maybe you can make a wiki page for key:westra_ref as well, so other people also understand what it means. I see the westra_ref is used even more frequent, is it also for mountain peaks?
Cheers,
dikkeknodel -
Comment from Alexheel
Yes,on Westra web site they have descriptions mountain passes and mountain peaks to. (More than 12000 nodes)
Cheers,
Alexheel
- St.Bernard (5636202354), v1
- Spielmannscharte (5636202355), v1
- Pointe des Portons (5636202356), v1
- Neve de la Rousse (5636202357), v1
- Montet (5636202358), v1
- Col du Petit Mont Collon (5636202359), v1
- Col du Gd St-Bernard (5636202360), v1
- Col du Brenay (5636202361), v1
- Col des Roux (5636202362), v1
- Col des Pariotes (5636202363), v1
- Col des Bouquetins (5636202364), v1
- Col de Tsa de Tsan (5636202365), v1
- Col de Tachuy (5636202366), v1
- Col de Charmotane (5636202367), v1
- Bec d-Aigle (5636202368), v1
- Triev (5636202369), v1
- Col de Tsofeiret (279111375), v4
- Aiguilles Dorées (290497880), v4
- Aiguille de Chardonnet (290497892), v6
- Col de Crête Sèche (302955197), v11
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |