Changeset: 59802554
Toll for HGV in Wallonia (rest)
Closed by franz1981mueller
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (13878 de) |
---|---|
review_requested | yes |
source | https://www.viapass.be/fileadmin/viapass/documents/download_de/2018_Kaarten_met_titels_DE_Wallonie.pdf |
Discussion
-
Comment from naoliv
Hello, Franz.
It seems that you did some sort of mechanical edit (https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Automated_edits) in your changesets.
For example, a lot of highway=motorway_junction nodes now have a toll:hgv=yes value (which which does not seem to make much sense).
Did you discuss this beforehand with the Belgian community, please? -
Comment from franz1981mueller
Hello naoliv, thank you for your comment.
Can you explain me why it does not make sense?
The toll in Belgium is tracked with a GPS-Onboard unit. The cost is calculated by km driven on a toll-road. If the junction is part of the toll-road, toll applies.
Thank you for your feedback!
-
Comment from franz1981mueller
Also additionally for your reference: http://www.axxes-bmap.com/simulator
-
Comment from naoliv
Hi! I mean the junction nodes (highway=motorway_junction), like this one https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/4444420372
"toll" (or "toll:hgv") is a tag https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:toll that should be used only on ways (thus using it on nodes like this isn't really right).
One of the reasons that I've asked if you did discuss this with the Belgian community is to avoid some possible mistakes, like this one for example. -
Comment from franz1981mueller
Hi! Thanks again for clarification.
Discussion is running here:
https://forum.openstreetmap.org/viewtopic.php?id=62619You are totally right regarding the nodes. We will undo it.
Cheers!
- E411 (4438836), v23
- A602 (5055810), v28
- Autoroute de Wallonie (4431991), v14
- E25;E411 (4545127), v30
- N90 (4573857), v9
- N4 (4680264), v18
- A7 (4862701), v19
- E429 (4903884), v15
- N89 (5028985), v19
- N89 (5029027), v25
- N89 (5029088), v14
- N89 (5029093), v8
- Rue des Fusillés (22717970), v12
- Grand Ring de Charleroi (4309827), v14
- E25 (4065498), v34
- E411 (4322140), v23
- E42 (5075802), v23
- A7 (5081957), v16
- Autoroute de Wallonie (5081959), v42
- E42 (5185014), v16
- Sterpenich (269514466), v9
- Fernelmont (676614), v6
- 33485393, v8
- 33580118, v5
- Petit-Rœulx (60630624), v15
- 60797371, v13
- 60797791, v16
- 24 (146605870), v20
- Spontin (247718930), v8
- 1 (248001313), v4
- Champion (145014), v9
- Léglise (141553), v6
- Transinne (619058), v10
- Manage (620298), v23
- Arlon (622386), v8
- Weyler (622393), v11
- Hingeon (1537031), v7
- 3807032, v12
- 3807036, v5
- Bouge (10451475), v8
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |