Changeset: 59812842
Pozsonyi magyar nevek
Closed by GBAB
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (13878 hu) |
---|---|
source | Oberpass-turbo |
Discussion
-
Comment from aceman444
Hi, why are you removing historic=castle+castle_type=palace from palaces in centre of Bratislava?
Adding historic=yes tag has not much value, it has no meaning.Also, you source=Oberpass-turbo (even with a typo) has a lie, the Hungarian names of the palaces surely do not come from Overpass turbo. Please provide real source of your data, otherwise it may be illegal and we will remove it.
-
Comment from GBAB
Dear Aceman444,
thanks for your comments and questions.
I changed the tags of the Bratislava city centre palaces because, in the OSM sense of the word, they are neither castles nor palaces:
https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:castle_type%3DpalaceThis is so even if they are called palác or palota in Slovak and in Hungarian. In OSM several words (tags, keys, values) have a more or less different meaning than they have in real life. (E.g. monument, of which I also changed some.)
The sources of the Hungarian names are a number of websites dealing with Bratislava, mostly www.pozsonyikifli.eu and www.muemlekem.hu
Of course, it may happen that some of the Hungarian names are not exact because I am a human, doing mistakes but I don't think they are completely wrong. So in this case it might be better to improve them rather than delete them.
Kind regards
Gabor Babos
-
Comment from aceman444
Hi. Thanks for the reply. Yes, I know some of the OSM values for tags are misleading and do not mean exactly what the word would normally mean. But castle_type=palace in OSM meaning (palace is a grand prestigious residence of aristocracy, mostly built in a town or city) is exactly what those buildings in Bratislava are. They do not need to be as large as on the OSM wiki page picture.
Yes, I've seen the changes of monument to memorial you have done and those are OK, thanks for spotting those errors.
Ways (7)
- Csákyho Palác (56305171), v7
- Georgievitsov palác (58376727), v4
- Aspremontov letný palác (77937443), v6
- Grasalkovičov palác (78068599), v16
- Pisztoryho palác (78147568), v11
- Karácsonyiho palác (90959701), v10
- Paluďaiho palác (485578750), v5
Relations (3)
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |