OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Moving lakes

Posted by larsf on 14 May 2010 in English.

I had to move a lake in Schwandt (Mecklemburg, Germany) which had originally been created by a different user. This lake just didn't fit into the bounds of the surrounding footpath I had surveyed.

I always feel uneasy changing stuff of other people, they might had a reason to do it that way that I am not able to grasp. This time I was a little pressed and went on simply because the original creator had stated landsat as source, which I could cross-check. As most of the other things this particular user had mapped in this area perfectly agreed with the landsat image I could get, I assumed that I had the image's bearings correct, and that somehow the image had changed in between, or the original creator had gotten something wrong.

In the name of cooperation I should inform the original creator. This could easily be done through the user-pages (I simply failed to find the correct one this time.)

Actually I don't know if there are any guidelines for such cases, and I would strictly vote against setting up such a thing for avoiding rule-discussions like they are familiar from the wikipedia community. But good behaviour should be to inform the other creators of a changed shape.

And by the way, if somebody comes through that area, I had to left some roads uncharted. These road-stubs look just silly and I'd like to improve on that. So, could anybody lay a track there? (Rare opportunity to introduce some new roads to the increasingly complete OSM-Map.)

Location: 17091, Wildberg, Treptower Tollensewinkel, Mecklenburgische Seenplatte, Mecklenburg-Vorpommern, Germany

Discussion

Comment from JohnSmith on 14 May 2010 at 17:26

There is plenty of unmapped roads in Australia if people want some "rare" opportunities :P

We even have some hi-res aerial imagery that has lots of unmapped roads in rural areas so you don't even need to leave the comfort of your own home for this once in a life time experience :D

Comment from whistle on 15 May 2010 at 00:49

In situations like this, when you have better data than the original, just go ahead and edit, it's unlikely that the original author will have a problem with it. I find that (at least in some regions?) the aerial photos are often misaligned, before doing any tracing it's best to make sure that the image is aligned with existing features on the map and if not, then align it manually. This is probably the source of the lake's misalignment, no big deal.

Log in to leave a comment