Changeset: 114085109
Initial upload of Bulkley Valley Nordic Centre trail data from our own GIS database.
Closed by bacforsyth
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (18303 en) |
---|---|
source | Bulkley Valley Nordic Centre mapping team's GIS database https://github.com/Bulkley-Valley-Cross-Country-Ski-Club/mapping |
Discussion
-
Comment from kartonage
Hi,
are you aware of the import guidelines (https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Import/Guidelines) and general code of conduct regarding automated edits (https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Automated_Edits_code_of_conduct)? It is unclear where your data is coming from exactly and if there is any user input in the process.
I have also read your description in "bvnordic:readme" and have to inform you that you can not request other users to contact you before editing as OpenStreetMap is about the ability for everyone to edit.
I would also suggest to keep meaningless values and tags like "bvnordic:commit-sha" out because they serve no purpose for OSM data or other users.Best regards
-
Comment from bacforsyth
Thanks for the feedback. I have submitted this changeset on behalf of the Bulkley Valley Cross Country Ski Club which maintains the trails in this changeset. The data comes from our GIS database in the linked to GitHub repository. It is maintained by our mapping team. The previous trails I deleted were out of date and rather than try to edit them manually we decided to start fresh from our QGIS data.
The bvnordic:readme tag was inspired from other cross country ski clubs. We are responsible for the accuracy of the trail data here and would very much like OSM contributors to consult with us before making changes.
The commit-sha links to our GitHub repo and may have been better off in the changeset description. -
Comment from mueschel
I found several more issues here:
- you deleted existing highways, leaving several other tracks unconnected, e.g. https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/643010169
- when highways cross, there needs to be a common node - these seem to be missing
- most of the piste ways already existed. It's recommended to update existing way instead of deleting and re-adding them.
- Down and Out X to V (1005156608), v1
- Wetzin'kwa L3 to Loop (1005156609), v1
- Connector Broadway to Dip (1005156610), v1
- Broadway L1 to L (1005156611), v1
- Demo Forest L5 to L1 (1005156612), v1
- The Way Home (1005156613), v1
- Pooch Paradise Fork to J (1005156614), v1
- Perimeter G to H (1005156615), v1
- Broadway L1 to L2 (1005156616), v1
- Wetzin'kwa L2 to Loop (1005156617), v1
- Perimeter F to C (1005156618), v1
- G to I (1005156619), v1
- Down and Out W to X (1005156620), v1
- Hound Heaven H to B (1005156621), v1
- Biathlon Loop (1005156622), v1
- Pine Creek Loop B to C (1005156623), v1
- Northern Lights A to W (1005156624), v1
- Broadway Stadium to Y (1005156625), v1
- Tunnel Connector (1005156626), v1
- Hound Heaven Fork to A (1005156627), v1
Relations (1-20 of 29)
- 1
- 2
- Pooch Paradise (13467595), v1
- Down and Out (13467596), v1
- Valley View (13467597), v1
- Pine Creek Loop (13467598), v1
- One Click Right (13467599), v1
- Biathlon Loop (13467600), v1
- West Connector (13467601), v1
- Broadway (13467602), v1
- Tunnel Connector (13467603), v1
- Wetzin'kwa (13467604), v1
- Wild Dog (13467605), v1
- Perimeter (13467606), v1
- Berminator (13467607), v1
- Hilltop Loop (13467608), v1
- 7.5 km Cut-Off (13467609), v1
- The Pup (13467610), v1
- Games (13467611), v1
- X-Y Connector (13467612), v1
- 5 km Cut-Off (13467613), v1
- Chris Dahlie Connector (13467614), v1
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |