Changeset: 117686222
update strange board_type value 'yes'
Closed by tkk
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (18360 en) |
---|---|
source | taginfo |
Discussion
- Comment from osmviborg
-
Comment from tkk
Yes, the size was a mistake, but I realize it only after submited. The intention was to limit this to CZ only with few related nodes.
-
Comment from Lee Carré
“strange board_type value 'yes'”
As a surveyor, my guess / assumption would be that they either didn't know, were in a rush (I've added barrier=yes, before), or the board-type was unclear (from the selection in whatever presets the mapper used).
So, if you're presuming to set a more specific type, what's your source for that? Surely it would require a survey?
-
Comment from tkk
Yes, ti will. For CZ (where I intended to make the change) it is (among other ways) done with photos collected in Fody project (for example: https://openstreetmap.cz/#map=15/50.7694/14.7777&layers=dGB). When I found, that it was applied to whole world, I was first thinking about a revert, but in this case, where board_type=yes makes no sense, I concluded it will be better to leave it as is and not create another large changeset.
-
Comment from Lee Carré
“it is (among other ways) done with photos collected in Fody project”
Should've set source to specify that, then.
“I was first thinking about a revert, but in this case, where board_type=yes makes no sense, I concluded it will be better to leave it as is and not create another large changeset.”
Changesets affect mappers, but data affects everyone.
Better another changeset to revert non-CZ boards, than incorrect data.
At least board_type=yes is a clue / signal that it needs more attention.
If arbitrarily set to something else, how would anyone know? For example, it would no longer show up as a StreetComplete quest.
-
Comment from InsertUser
Where was this mechanical edit discussed?
---
Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/117686222
-
Comment from tkk
Why do you think this was mechanical edit?
- Bürgstadt Info Gäste (305762357), v4
- Der Steinberg (339915858), v4
- Wasserscheide Donau Rhein (414098164), v4
- Start Trimm-Dich-Pfad (443720962), v4
- Información Turística (444186208), v9
- Uferweg (566327724), v6
- 691841786, v3
- The Prospect From Aberdour (738156042), v3
- 1248318019, v4
- 1282205550, v3
- Boreid, Langøy, Gumøy, Bæreøy, Jomfruland (1343913043), v5
- 1398975739, v3
- 1763748976, v4
- 1771005220, v3
- Rowy egzekucyjne (1905483411), v5
- 2022396641, v5
- Carte de quartier (2187459325), v4
- 2195656097, v4
- Kulturdenkmal Oderteich (2356937158), v5
- 2485500570, v3
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |