Changeset: 134796108
removed highway=proposed ways related to Blue Line LRT extension following discussion in OSM slack #local-minnesota
Closed by zbrown4
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (18360 Debian en) |
---|---|
hashtags | #local-minnesota |
source | Bing |
Discussion
-
Comment from Jacorp
Hey what the heck, why was the proposed Blue Line extension deleted? I put a lot of work into that. I understand that there is a part of the route that hasn't been finalized yet (assuming that's why it was deleted) but you didn't have to delete the whole thing. It will probably be finalized soon, so hopefully there is a way to recover all of that easily.
-
Comment from Jacorp
Meant to add the last comment to changeset 134796569 instead.
-
Comment from zbrown4
Hey - prior to removing these ways I asked other local mappers for their opinion regarding 'proposed' ways. The general consensus was that 'highway/railway=proposed' ways are not appropriate for OSM as they are not verifiable on the ground, and as you mentioned, the route is subject to change. The 'proposed' value itself is a disputed subject on OSM (see https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Talk:Key:proposed#Verifiable? and https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:highway%3Dproposed)
Once construction starts, it would be valid to add the ways as railway=construction.
If you disagree, you are welcome to join the OpenStreetMap Slack #local-minnesota channel and voice your opinion. This changeset (and/or 134796569) can be reverted if there is agreement with others.
- 74th Way North (6011179), v8
- 83rd Avenue North (6011764), v10
- 75th Avenue North (6014998), v7
- 6042813, v2
- College Parkway (93915655), v15
- Brooklyn Boulevard (116950904), v16
- 468936914, v2
- Starlite Center (520624364), v8
- Brooklyn Boulevard (521246807), v11
- 546175906, v7
- Maplebrook Parkway North (624713974), v9
- Maplebrook Terrace North (624713975), v8
- 625504072, v6
- 625504079, v6
- 625504098, v9
- Brooklyn Boulevard (639530957), v7
- 85th Avenue North (639783640), v8
- 703219386, v5
- Brooklyn Boulevard (703229641), v3
- 76th Avenue North (703229647), v4
Relations (11)
- 103 (1618100), v28
- 130 (1618146), v35
- Metro Transit 723 (northbound) (8868667), v34
- Metro Transit 724 (southbound) (8868675), v32
- Metro Transit 705B (northbound) (8868684), v42
- Metro Transit 705B (southbound) (8868685), v37
- Metro Transit 705A (northbound) (8868686), v44
- Metro Transit 705A (southbound) (8868687), v37
- Metro Transit 764 (northbound) (8873165), v38
- Metro Transit 764 (southbound) (8873166), v32
15654241, v2
- 10803426304, v1
- 10803440505, v1
- 10803440506, v1
- 10803440507, v1
- 10803440508, v1
- 10803440509, v1
- 10803440510, v1
- 33315509, v6
- 34526047, v4
- 5073990448, v2
- 5073990451, v2
- 5073990459, v2
- 6603965405, v2
- 6604034799, v2
- 6604047231, v3
- 7165095958, v2
- 7589594067, v2
- 7977145438, v2
- 7982010750, v3
33315467, v5
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |