Changeset: 138822498
NL - simplified almost all 1-member relations to ways (excl. 3 provinces that I did earlier)
Closed by Friendly_Ghost
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (18772 en_GB) |
---|---|
source | Luchtfoto Actueel Ortho HR (7,5 cm) Beeldmateriaal.nl (OSM OK)(wms); BRP Gewaspercelen |
Discussion
-
Comment from Allroads
https://www.openstreetmap.org/relation/11915097/history
Then you could see that I forgot here to insert a inner https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/875076783#map=19/52.68786/5.90694Did you noticed that?
Why not include the inner?
This should be right.
Now it is still wrong. Not cutting out the water.Also for this way https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/874439809/history
Not a problem when you contact met up front.
-
Comment from Friendly_Ghost
There are many cases of landuse polygons containing or intersecting water areas. It usually doesn't hinder rendering and it's at the very bottom of my priority list, also in all of my other changesets.
If it makes a difference to you I could tidy up a bunch of them.
-
Comment from Allroads
In the base, it is wrong, what rendering does, should not effect good tagging, leave it as it is, is wrong.
As you did not mention that you have seen it, I assume that "you walked over it" Not noticed the situation, why there was a multipolygon, recognize my fault.
But still set back as a polygon.
This looks like a mechanical, so there is now a double mistake. I aspected with such a cleaning, that you noticed it, if you did it on purpose, that is not okay.Did you notice the slope=yes tag?
-
Comment from Friendly_Ghost
As you can see in the changeset source I was using the aerial imagery to verify each and every single one of all the objects that I changed. There wasn't anything "mechanical" about this edit.
You can't claim that I added any mistakes to the map here, because the water bodies weren't part of the multipolygons in the first place. As I mentioned previously, this can still easily be done. I just don't happen to have my pc with me this week.
I did notice the slope tag, but since I have no idea what the tag means I didn't do anything with it.
-
Comment from Friendly_Ghost
There are thousands of cases where landuse/natural polygons overlap with water, see for example this simple query for Amsterdam: https://overpass-turbo.eu/s/1ywp
Evidently, when you consider the whole Netherlands, the number of overlapping landuse and water polygons will become big enough that fixing them should be considered a separate project.
-
Comment from Allroads
The point is that you did not see/understand my mistake and responded to it by adding the inner, my intention, which is correct then setting it to polygon.
-
Comment from Friendly_Ghost
Did you just comment to complain about my changeset or do you want to improve the map together?
-
Comment from Allroads
I noticed it at first here, the way relation change https://resultmaps.neis-one.org/osm-edits-tile/#14/52.6840/5.9059, now it is past 14 days. So now and then I look here what is changed in some area. I did this part of nature.
Asking myself, why, why not set the inner correct, my failure, that's why this reaction on the changeset is made, to make together a better map. So I brought it to your attention.
Obvious, in this case, I find it wrong. I did not watch other changes in the changeset. But if it is done like this case, then it is questionable. That is now my comment on the changeset, since you asked for it. -
Comment from Friendly_Ghost
Alright, that makes it very understandable. Thank you for clarifying.
You're right of course that I could have made proper multipolygons with the water, but since I wasn't looking for it I missed it.
- Dentgenbach (6318187), v29
- RWZI Stein (6318231), v7
- Vlissingen-Oost (6318547), v20
- Kampina (6323080), v20
- 6330466, v16
76744180, v281012321, v6- Richel (8166604), v12
- 27400840, v21
- 30858436, v49
- Stadsboerderij Koppelsteede (32549818), v11
- 35094795, v6
- Heycopplein (37639551), v12
- 46049925, v4
- 46050768, v5
- 46496817, v5
- 46700107, v5
- 46826317, v6
- 47013478, v5
- 47065625, v11
- 1082341, v6
- 1371518, v4
360396, v4360432, v4368139, v4370659, v5372532, v5372533, v4546500, v4550650, v6550652, v4901051, v4958019, v41015766, v31157026, v51169299, v41169303, v51169326, v41169331, v51169333, v4
Nodes (19)
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |