Changeset: 148173600
improved coastline from os boundary-line, added some missing islets and bays
Closed by ancuanatuath
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (18969 en_GB) |
---|---|
source | Bing; NLS - OS 6-inch Scotland 1842-82; OS OpenMap Local (October 2023); OS OpenData StreetView (April 2016); NLS - OS 1:10,000/1:10,560, 1949-1972 |
Discussion
-
Comment from tms13
Please stop breaking the continuity of North Uist. I've repaired this twice in two days; I don't want to keep re-doing that.
-
Comment from ancuanatuath
It was rebroken due to a conflict with your changeset fixing the relation, so sorry about that and thanks for fixing it. I'd appreciate if you were less accusative though - breaking the relation obviously wasn't intentional.
-
Comment from tms13
Sorry - it looked like you were deliberately ignoring the fix. I was clearly in a bad mood that day!
As an aside, do you agree with me that Rockall and North Rona/Sula Sgeir should be removed from the "Hebrides" relation, whether or not they are administered by Comhairle nan Eilean Siar? I've never considered these outliers to be Hebridean, and Wikipedia concurs. -
Comment from ancuanatuath
Personally I don't really have an opinion on that - I find the Hebridean relations somewhat unwieldy and mostly ignore them, but it's almost impossible to avoid editing them when dealing with Hebridean coastlines. Removing Rockall etc. would at least result in smaller changeset bounding boxes which would be nice, but I don't have an opinion on whether that would be "correct".
- 1257174811, v1
- 1257174812, v1
- 1257174813, v1
- 1257174814, v1
- 1257174815, v1
- 1257174816, v1
- 1257174817, v1
- 1257174818, v1
- 1257174819, v1
- 1257174820, v1
- 1257174821, v1
- 1257174822, v1
- 1257174823, v1
- 1257174824, v1
- 1257174825, v1
- 1257174826, v1
- 1257174827, v1
- 1257174828, v1
- 1257174829, v1
- 1257174830, v1
Relations (4)
- Riffagan (17300904), v1
- Uibhist a Tuath (380685), v52
- Na h-Eileanan Siar (1959008), v402
- Hebrides (16304905), v23
- 11688030031, v1
- 11688030032, v1
- 11688030033, v1
- 11688030034, v1
- 11688030035, v1
- 11688030036, v1
- 11688030037, v1
- 11688030038, v1
- 11688030039, v1
- 11688030040, v1
- 11688030041, v1
- 11688030042, v1
- 11688030043, v1
- 11688030044, v1
- 11688030045, v1
- 11688030046, v1
- 11688030047, v1
- 11688030048, v1
- 11688030049, v1
- 11688030050, v1
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |