Changeset: 26537333
(no comment)
Closed by OdysseyResorts
Tags
created_by | iD 1.6.2 |
---|---|
imagery_used | Bing;MAPNIK |
Discussion
-
Comment from OdysseyResorts
Updated information about Caribou Highlands Lodge
-
Comment from emacsen
Unless the name of every single of these buildings that have the name "Caribou Highlands Lodge Poplar Ridge Homes" on them, then this changeset is too spammy and will be reverted.
Please fix.
-
Comment from OdysseyResorts
I can definitely change these. What would you recommend for the naming of the buildings? There are several different styles of buildings at this resort. 9 of them are Poplar Ridge Homes, 5 are town homes, 2 are executive lodges, 3 are condo buildings and 1 is a lodge. They are all part of one resort property, Caribou Highlands Lodge.
-
Comment from emacsen
If each building has a name, like the "Caribu Lodge"- then go ahead and change the name to that. What are you trying to indicate- that these are lodges available as part of the resort?
-
Comment from OdysseyResorts
Yes. The entire resort property called Caribou Highlands Lodge is made up of 20 buildings. We refer to these buildings as condos, lodge, town homes, and poplar ridge homes. My naming was an attempt to show they are part of the same property, but designate their differences. So I could get rid of the "caribou highlands lodge" portion, but I think that would be less helpful. It is one business.
-
Comment from emacsen
I don't know if this is really your first OSM edit (it's your first one on this account). If so- this is a pretty amazing job. To indicate buildings are part of the same property, you could use something called a relation- which I can show you how to create (it's just a bit complex).
Otherwise, I'd just use a single node to represent the resort.
The problem with having it on every building is twofold. First, unless they each are named that, then it's not accurate. You could name each one what you call it internally, eg "Building 12" if there's a sign on it saying so.
The second and more glaring problem is that most of the time, the reason someone puts a name on an object is so that it's rendered with the name, so right now we have a bunch of buildings with the name of the resort, which reads too much like spam. Let me know, and I can also help fix it if you need help.
-
Comment from EdLoach
I don't know whether this is relevant, but there is an area near me that has holiday homes for rent where the whole area has been mapped as landuse=commercial (for lack of a suitable tourism tag) and the individual buildings with their numbers. http://www.openstreetmap.org/way/129105350#map=16/51.8226/1.0647
-
Comment from AndrewBuck
The best thing to do would be to put the name of the resort in the 'operator' tag for the buildings. I don't think the iD editor displays a box for that field by default, you will have to click the 'All tags' button and then add a new one with a key of 'operator' and for the value put in the resort name.
Ways (1-20 of 38)
- 1
- 2
- Caribou Highlands Lodge Main Lodge (311035162), v1
- Caribou Highlands Lodge Condo Building B (311035163), v1
- Caribou Highlands Lodge Condo Building C (311035164), v1
- 311035165, v1
- 311035166, v1
- 311035167, v1
- 311035169, v1
- 311035170, v1
- 311035171, v1
- 311035172, v1
- 311035173, v1
- 311035174, v1
- Caribou Highlands Lodge Executive Lodges (311035175), v1
- Caribou Highlands Lodge Executive Lodges (311035177), v1
- Caribou Highlands Lodge Townhomes (311035178), v1
- Caribou Highlands Lodge Townhomes (311035179), v1
- Caribou Highlands Lodge Townhomes (311035180), v1
- Caribou Highlands Lodge Townhomes (311035181), v1
- Caribou Highlands Lodge Townhomes (311035182), v1
- Caribou Highlands Lodge Poplar Ridge Homes (311035183), v1
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |