Changeset: 27867757
Fixing address tags using contact:*=* instead of addr:*=*
Closed by gileri
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (7906 fr) |
---|
Discussion
-
Comment from woodpeck
This is a rather large-scale mechanical edit. Has it been discussed before it was executed? Otherwise I'd ask you to please revert it and secure a community consensus before you run it again.
-
Comment from gileri
Is there any problem regarding the data corrected by this changeset ? I am welcome to any suggestion or remark to better OSM data, if anyone have any.
-
Comment from yxoc
Hello,
You have changed in Montrouge the contact:* keys of some shops in addr:*. This is a problem since the adresses are now duplicated (there are already adress nodes
for the buildings), as you can see easily on osmose. Had you looked into the history of these nodes you would have seen that I had previously changed the addr:* into contact:* precisely for that reason. -
Comment from gileri
Ralf: If I get you right you mean you used an seemingly redundant, almost-unused tag, with only one reference in the wiki to input addresses which are already present on the surrounding building, in order to avoid errors on tools like osmose ?
The reason osmose didn't flag the way this feature has been mapped is because the tag is not know to osmose.
I'm not sure it's the correct approach for grouping features under the same (address-wise) roof.
Anyway thanks for your input on this changeset.
-
Comment from woodpeck
Reverted in changeset 28095080. Any future similar edits must adhere to the existing mechanical edit policy.
-
Comment from gileri
By reading the MEP wiki page, I'm not sure my edit falls under it. As stated on the "search-and-replace" section, changesets such as this one, as the data I modified is backed by the wiki, and the data on the features itselves.
So, as you deleted my work, may I ask you to tell me (whether here or in private) what qualify "similar edits", in order to avoid wasting contributors time in the future ? As all contributors, my time is limited and I think I deserve, as much as anyone, that my volunteer work "stay on the map".
Thank you.
-
Comment from yxoc
gileri: I am not sure either that the contact:* scheme is the best way to map multiple POI's under the same address, but it is the one which is recommended here in France. Anyway, there seems to be a consensus that duplicated addresses (with addr:* keys) wrong.
-Ralf.
- Alain Jaume & fils (78618664), v9
- Amazonia (78618618), v15
- Application Mécanique Hydraulique (78619349), v16
- Argensol peintures (79249867), v10
- Art'TeaStic (33140417), v6
- Atelier traitement Surface (79251423), v11
- Au Potager BIO (245759499), v8
- Bahn-BKK (93642385), v7
- Besancon Demangel (72032735), v5
- Besancon Palente (72591392), v7
- Bio best (78618456), v12
- Business Tower (135411846), v11
- 35355871, v8
- 95094124, v6
- 64931607, v5
- Carrosserie JM Poizac (78625418), v9
- Centre spirituel En Guédi (44308232), v5
- Century 21 CAI Carquefou (129161610), v6
- Channel Fret (78618852), v11
- Collège Gilbert Cousin (305616009), v3
Relations (4)
- Naturpark Hohes Venn-Eifel (Nordeifel) (334377), v17
- Tanka-Lindesberg (2581445), v3
- 4112610, v5
- Orange (1654142), v5
- A la Guill'on Dîne (2242967273), v5
- A'tout peinture (2956549865), v5
- ADS 72 (2856599038), v6
- Agentur für Arbeit (392255097), v9
- Alimentation Générale (1768571322), v6
- Alimentation (1704383061), v9
- Amphithéâtre Charles Mérieux (2432962337), v3
- Angélique (1802845584), v5
- Aquarium Tropical (1809720087), v3
- Arbeitskreis selbständiger Kultur-Institute e.V. (1753156503), v3
- Architekten Thomas Hieronymi & Ute Hieronymi (1476363740), v3
- Armurerie Garnier (1300589414), v8
- Artschys Fahrschule (2498128275), v3
- Asie B7 (2529758976), v3
- Atelier 33 (2120500204), v7
- Au Coeur de l'Italie (1768583150), v5
- Au Paradis Nuptial (1802838478), v6
- Au Vieux Campeur (585345048), v10
- Aux Bons Crus (2282579428), v3
- Azra viandes (1349385522), v5
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |