Changeset: 36846890
Road alignment to aerial imagery.
Closed by West Lake
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (8800 en) |
---|---|
source | Bing |
Discussion
-
Comment from jc86035
Please don't re-tag trunk routes not classified as highways (i.e. with green signs), or not in tunnel areas, as motorways (highway=motorway). These roads should be tagged as trunk roads (highway=trunk).
-
Comment from West Lake
Apologies. I was assuming because they met all criteria for motorways they should be upgraded for routing consistency as well as rendering consistency. Is there a resource you use to verify which roads are trunk vs. motorway? (i.e. list of route names/classifications)
Thanks
-W -
Comment from jc86035
OSM Wiki page: https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/HK:Hong_Kong_tagging#.E8.A1.97.E9.81.93.E5.88.86.E9.A1.9E_Classifications_of_streets
Generally, expressways in Hong Kong are distinguished by green destination signs and kilometre markings. Most of them are part of the route system, but two (Penny's Bay Highway and Sha Lek Road) are not.
Tunnels and tunnel areas are also tagged as highway=motorway. (In my nearly three years here I have yet to find out why, but I digress.)
-
Comment from jc86035
FYI the reason the situation currently looks so inconsistent is because user 00crashtest, for some reason, decided without any community discussion whatsoever to tag every road without an at-grade intersection as highway=motorway. I have asked data@openstreetmap.org to revert this change, per https://help.openstreetmap.org/questions/47773/problems-with-mass-retagging-and-others.
-
Comment from woodpeck
I'll attempt to fix this later today.
- 1 (46108740), v18
- 1 (46108742), v12
- 1 (85320767), v5
- 1 (244383689), v4
- 1 (268592366), v4
- 1 (46097654), v16
- 1 (87148772), v6
- 1 (251357691), v6
- 4 (87081200), v8
- 4 (244383597), v4
- 4 (46108744), v13
- 4 (254033425), v2
- 4 (32551394), v28
- 4 (26448475), v17
- 堅拿道天橋 Canal Road Flyover (261027970), v6
- 堅拿道天橋 Canal Road Flyover (251367673), v4
- 堅拿道天橋 Canal Road Flyover (295102559), v4
- 堅拿道天橋 Canal Road Flyover (251368361), v4
- 堅拿道天橋 Canal Road Flyover (87148750), v4
- 堅拿道天橋 Canal Road Flyover (84658865), v7
Nodes (19)
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |