Changeset: 39426586
Corrections Osmose
Closed by Luuuddooo
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (10161 fr) |
---|---|
source | Osmose;Bing;cadastre-dgi-fr source : Direction Générale des Finances Publiques - Cadastre. Mise à jour : 2016 |
Discussion
-
Comment from highflyer74
Hello!
I noticed you changed some address data to contact:postcode etc. This is wrong. The initial version was correct. contact:* is used for phone, website etc.
Happy mapping!
-
Comment from Luuuddooo
This correspond to this way of mapping: http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/House_numbers/Bremen_Schema#Motivation
It is the recomended way of doing in France (http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/WikiProject_France/WikiProject_Base_Adresses_Nationale_Ouverte_%28BANO%29) when adresses are duplicated which was the case here (it was repported as an error by http://osmose.openstreetmap.fr)
-
Comment from highflyer74
Hello and thanks for your quick reply!
Then this seems to be a "french only" way of tagging things. The discussion about having duplicate adresses is still going on, and although I (and I guess all other mappers) would love to have a general consent on such a basic issue, there is no consent yet.
The first link you sent leads to a draft, which has not been voted on nor has it been approved in any way, as far as I can see. So I don't think this should be used in everyday tagging.
In my opinion it only makes sense to apply such a serious change in tagging worldwide and not only in one country. Do you know if there has been a discussion on that in any international mailing list or forum?
-
Comment from Luuuddooo
OK thanks, I will stop doing this kind of modification then. Sorry I don't know I don't follow international mailing lists.
-
Comment from highflyer74
Maybe you can check on the French forum / mailinglists about the status of that idea. I just asked on the German forum to see if anybody knows anything there. Thank you for your answers anyway! I'll let you know what they say over here :-)
- Chemin du Thon (162015067), v2
- D (98434598), v5
- Gymnase (97582553), v3
- G (98434113), v5
- H (98433583), v5
- I (98433638), v5
- J (98432886), v6
- Maison pour Tous de Chateauvert (97497944), v3
- M (98433704), v6
- O (98433076), v3
- P1 (419479268), v2
- P2 (419479269), v2
- P3 (419479270), v2
- P4 (207166837), v3
- Rue Léo Delibes (99324459), v2
- 72588909, v2
- 97494824, v2
- 97484245, v3
- 72588383, v3
- 419479328, v2
Relations (5)
- A (1471733), v3
- 1546078, v5
- École élémentaire d'application Jean de La Fontaine (1572306), v5
- Robinson (2169349), v3
1546118, v5
- M.J.C. Chateauvert (4195417708), v1
- 4195417709, v1
- 4195417710, v1
- 4195417711, v1
- 4195417712, v1
- 4195417713, v1
- 4195417714, v1
- 4195417715, v1
- 4195417716, v1
- 4195417717, v1
- 4195417718, v1
- 4195417719, v1
- 4195417720, v1
- 4195417721, v1
- 4195417722, v1
- 4195417723, v1
- 4195417724, v1
- 4195417725, v1
- 4195417726, v1
- 4195417727, v1
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |