Changeset: 42463318
Localites OCHA
Closed by carlitos gomez
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (10327 fr) |
---|---|
source | OCHA - REACH |
Discussion
-
Comment from mueschel
Hi,
did you check all those 700 imported nodes for validity? I can see several issues here:
- there are keys that do not belong into the OSM database, like COM_NOM and PREF_NOM.
- in many cases I checked, the nodes are not in the correct place
- in many cases, like the one linked below, the actual village already has been mapped in great detail.
http://www.openstreetmap.org/node/4419990299#map=16/4.8355/23.2373
Please consult the general guidelines for important, and review all these edits.
http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Import/Guidelines
Jan -
Comment from edvac
This changeset seems to be an import. Has it been discussed and followed the import guidelines? Otherwise, it should be reverted and then redone following the correct process.
-
Comment from carlitos gomez
Hi
I followed the guidelines. If I made mistakes, can you explain me because I do not understand where is the problem.
Tags: COM_NON, PREF_NOM AND SPREF_NOM: I use these tags to be able to geolocate localities more easily. Most of these tags have been deleted already. Some localities have sill not checked and tags not removed -
Comment from edvac
If you followed the import guidelines, could you please provide the url of the wiki for this import? It's not present in the changeset tags or anywhere else.
-
Comment from edvac
Hi: It's already 3 years since I asked you to provide the url of the wiki for this import. No answer. There are 160 places, many of them badly located (out of any residential area), and with uncommented tags (comming most probably from shapefiles or similar), like COM_NOM, PREF_NOM and SPREF_NOM
Do you understand that this behaviour, ignoring other mappers, is not exactly the best way to build a better map and a better community?
- Zacko 9 (4419990690), v1
- Zakcko 2 (4419990691), v1
- Zaloua (4419990692), v1
- Zawara (4419990693), v1
- Ziangba (4419990694), v1
- Ziangba (4419990695), v1
- Zidro (4419990696), v1
- Zime (4419990697), v1
- Zimé 2 (4419990698), v1
- Zimé (4419990699), v1
- Zimé (4419990700), v1
- Zobé-Mbari (4419990701), v1
- Zoko (4419990702), v1
- Zolémo (4419990703), v1
- Zongo (4419990704), v1
- Zotté (4419990705), v1
- Zoukouzou (4419990706), v1
- Zoundoukou (4419990707), v1
- Zémio (4419990708), v1
- Zémoyé (4419990709), v1
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |