Changeset: 46284905
Doing my Patriotic duty and importing Canvec Tile #22E01
Closed by gfysgerm
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (11529 en) |
---|---|
source | NRCan-Canvec-10 |
Discussion
-
Comment from woodpeck
Importing Canvec data requires some diligence. You cannot just take a Canvec tile and dump it into OSM (else others would have done it long ago). You need to compare Canvec data to existing data or even aerial imagery to make sure you're not making the map worse. See for example https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/476144472 where you have imported a patch of green landcover that sits completely beside the island in Lac Carrier where it belongs - either you need to fix the landcover or the island. Same for almost all the forest you imported bordering Lac Carrier; being of a much inferior resolution compared to the lake itself, the woodland cuts into and out of the lake at random. Please don't insult Canadians by calling this kind of mapping a "patriotic duty", and try to place quality over quantity in the future.
-
Comment from woodpeck
It appears you have imported a new road over an already existing road here https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/476144200#map=18/49.12053/-70.11346&layers=D and tagged the new road with "lanes=-1"?
-
Comment from LogicalViolinist
I'll fix it up, not sure why JOSM didnt catch that error, I might have to reset my settings.
-
Comment from LogicalViolinist
both instances have been fixed. will check if there's anymore data that had already been added that is overlapping
- 476142072, v1
- 476142073, v1
- 476142074, v1
- 476142076, v1
- 476142078, v1
- 476142081, v1
- 476142082, v1
- 476142084, v1
- 476142086, v1
- 476142088, v1
- 476142089, v1
- 476142090, v1
- 476142092, v1
- 476142094, v1
- 476142096, v1
- Lac des Baies (476142100), v1
- 476142103, v1
- 476142105, v1
- 476142107, v1
- 476142108, v1
- 7000350, v1
- Lac Carrier (7000351), v1
- 7000352, v1
- Lac de la Tour (7000353), v1
- 7000354, v1
- 7000355, v1
- 7000356, v1
- Lac en Huit (7000357), v1
- Lac Robert-Picard (7000358), v1
- 7000359, v1
- 7000360, v1
- Lac du Taon (7000361), v1
- 7000362, v1
- 7000363, v1
- 7000364, v1
- 7000365, v1
- 7000366, v1
- 7000367, v1
- 7000368, v1
- 7000369, v1
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |