Changeset: 51100923
Bus routes around Oslo
Closed by Polyglot
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (12556 en) |
---|
Discussion
-
Comment from Noen
Hi!
This changeset seems to focus on splitting roads on public_transport=stop_position nodes at the start/end of bus routes. Is this really necessary?
There is a warning for this in the JOSM validator, but i can't find anything on this issue in wiki.openstreetmap, the talk mailing list or the talk-transit mailing list.Be careful not to split incomplete bus routes.
-
Comment from Polyglot
I started doing this in bus stations, but I'm convinced that it makes a lot of sense at the beginning and end of the routes.
I'm 'traveling' around the world to test the PT_Assistant plugin and also to see how public transport is being mapped in different places. -
Comment from chillly
So you're not really travelling and seeing what is really there, you're making undiscussed, mass edits from the comfort of your armchair. Do you think this is a good idea and that it is acceptable?
-
Comment from Polyglot
Of course I think it's acceptable or I wouldn'tbe doing it. I agree the changesets are big and it would be better that locals do them.
They take hours of time to work on though. Splitting ways has the consequence of affecting several other route relations, which in turn need to checked too.
I see it as a form of quality control.
I do agree that adding public_transport=platform to the bus_station was probably not the best solution. It would be far better to have a public_transport=platform node and add those to the route relations, but that is information that I don't have and in this case it could also not be inferred from what was already mapped previously. So there is still a lot of work to do for you guys. I hope the JOSM's PT_Assistant pluign can help you do that in a more efficient way.
- Østensjøveien (515436431), v1
- Øvre Ryensvei (515436432), v1
- Munkedamsveien (515436433), v1
- Langkaigata (515436434), v1
- Hadelandsvegen (515436435), v1
- Prestegårdsveien (515436436), v1
- 515436437, v1
- 515436438, v1
- Sykehusveien (515436439), v1
- Nesåsveien (515436440), v1
- Hadelandsveien (515436441), v1
- 515436442, v1
- 515436443, v1
- Hadelandsveien (515436444), v1
- Prestegårdsveien (515436445), v1
- Ulvenveien (515436446), v1
- 515436447, v1
- 515436448, v1
- Ulvenveien (515436449), v1
- 515436450, v1
- Sykkelrute E18 (13653), v114
- Ring 1 (899059), v52
- 321 (1452725), v137
- 321 (1542264), v107
- 331 (1544408), v23
- 160 (1560135), v90
- 220 (1590713), v22
- Østensjøveien (1631455), v19
- 70 (1912028), v58
- 80E (2029185), v107
- 81A (2131826), v79
- 81B (2131827), v73
- 84E (2135416), v77
- 82E (2135417), v75
- 54 (2308029), v28
- 401 (2319719), v41
- 401 (2319720), v46
- 71A (2335343), v16
- 83 (2363229), v63
- 54 (2366440), v27
- 5033816040, v1
- 33584510, v3
- 36433103, v6
- Grorudkrysset (87206620), v5
- Dokkveien (347537815), v10
- 372934740, v4
- Lillestrøm terminal (1243685057), v4
- Lillestrøm terminal (1243685086), v4
- Lillestrøm terminal (1243685089), v4
- Lillestrøm terminal (1243685093), v4
- Lillestrøm terminal (1243685103), v4
- Lillestrøm terminal (1243685134), v4
- Olavsgaard (1244541092), v4
- Olavsgaard (1244541114), v4
- Olavsgaard (1244541117), v4
- Olavsgaard (1244541137), v4
- Olavsgaard (1244541148), v4
- Olavsgaard (1244541164), v4
- Lufthavnen, Udenrigsterminal (1310612418), v2
- Grorud T (1801764568), v6
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |