Changeset: 57034975
Update school edubase ID's and names using DfE data from https://get-information-schools.service.gov.uk/ under OGL.
Closed by Robert Whittaker
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (13500 en_GB) |
---|
Discussion
-
Comment from DaveF
Hi
Was this block amendment discussed anywhere? -
Comment from Robert Whittaker
No -- do you think it should have been?
I'm not sure exactly what your concerns are, but (a) the use of the DfE data for UK Schools is well-established, and (b) I wouldn't regard the changeset as a mechanical edit as each change was examined individually before being included in the changeset.
The changes were made based on official data from https://get-information-schools.service.gov.uk/ that said a school with a now-definct ID had a successor institution with the new ID. I used the data extracted by my tool in the table at
http://robert.mathmos.net/osm/schools/matching-queries.html#no-ref-successor
to manually check that the school still had essentially the same name, and was in roughly the correct location. For such objects, I concluded the ID change was just administrative, and so could be updated safely. Given the nature of the changes (updating the ID and in some cases changing the name to the official name supplied by the school to the DfE) I felt this was sufficient verification for each change. (The currently remaining entries in the table above are the ones I rejected in my initial pass as needing a fuller investigation before making any changes. I haven't got round to looking into those yet.) -
Comment from DaveF
My concern is the name change. Similar to road & shop names, the one on the ground should be used. In databases they're often manipulated to suit the needs of the compiler.
A heads-up on Talk-GB would have been nice.
- Comment from DaveF
- Upton Heath CofE Primary School (130918983), v5
- Sprowston Community Academy (134236851), v6
- St Crispin's School (135978362), v7
- Kenninghall Primary School (142044714), v9
- Holybrook Primary School (144456283), v4
- Galmpton Church of England Primary School (159070179), v3
- West Row Community Primary School (160150482), v5
- Backwell Church of England Junior School (161116279), v4
- St Botolphs CofE Academy (174624565), v4
- West Vale Primary School (194901722), v5
- Ashill Community Primary School (197707068), v3
- Goldthorn Park Primary School (203911293), v6
- North Walsham Junior School (208732342), v9
- North Walsham Infant School and Nursery (208733635), v6
- Airy Hill Primary School (216867542), v5
- Flegg High Ormiston Academy (217469670), v8
- Northleaze Church of England Primary School (218879805), v7
- Trumpington Community College (225540642), v9
- Salford Priors CofE Academy (227417168), v3
- Highbury Grove School (230254472), v8
Relations (8)
- Bignold Primary School and Nursery (2237512), v5
- Grafham Grange School (6066321), v3
- Tyntesfield Primary School (6454356), v3
- Chapelford Village Primary School (6454390), v3
- Burtonwood Community Primary School (6454399), v3
- Parish Church of England Primary School (6454411), v3
- The Meadows School (6717198), v2
- Canon Slade CofE School (7843590), v2
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |