Changeset: 60111716
deleted duplicate ways in part of Montebello Islands Marine Park, Western Australia
Closed by cleary
Tags
build | 2.5-37-ga38498b2 |
---|---|
created_by | Potlatch 2 |
version | 2.5 |
Discussion
-
Comment from RoundCircle
G'day Cleary,
I recently began importing the Australian marine parks and noticed that you have made a start as well!
Unfortunately, the CAPAD 2016 data is out of date because new management plans began for almost all commonwealth reserves on the 1st of this month. Most importantly:
*"Commonwealth Marine Reserves" are now called "Marine Parks".
*Outer boundaries are unchanged, but there have been a lot of internal zoning changes (i.e. Sanctuary Zone, etc).But don't worry, I have already updated your contributions as part of my import progress.
-
Comment from RoundCircle
And just to clarify my methods,
I have not included the zoning of the reserves in my imports for a few reasons:
*It's not in CAPAD! (yet).
*A single marine park is more straightforward for OSM users.
*I am using Wikidata tags which reference the reserve as a whole (this is not a limitation, but mostly because of the following points:)
*I would argue that the zones are not distinct entities of the marine park.
*Easier to import and manage.
Regards,
Lee -
Comment from RoundCircle
Oh bugger, I commented on the wrong changeset.
I was explaining my reasoning for the Commonwealth reserves only. -
Comment from TheSwavu
Please stop importing any more of this data. We only have permission from DoEE to use the CAPAD datasets. We do not have permission to use any of their other data sets. This will have to wait till 2019 when the CAPAD2018 gets released.
Also please stop importing anything else without discussing it on the mail list first:https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-au This is not only polite it also required under the import guidelines:https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Import/Guidelines
Thank you.
-
Comment from RoundCircle
Just to clarify this is CAPAD 2016 data, with names extrapolated from the review.
-
Comment from cleary
I think TheSwavu's point still stands. As far as I know we don't yet have permission to use any data, including names, from your new source. Some of the data in OSM quickly becomes obsolete and one of the merits of OSM is the ability to update it quickly - as long as it is from permitted sources.
In regard to the zones in marine parks, they are mapped separately in CAPAD and I think that, if we use a source, we should be accurate especially as there are different uses permitted and different levels of protection in zones. We wouldn't map a large area such as a city and omit suburb divisions and suggest that was better for users of the map. Generally the better the detail in a map, the more useful it is.
-
Comment from RoundCircle
I have continued the discussion in the mailing list.
Regards,
Lee -
Comment from Warin61
Hi,
The relation for Montebello Islands Marine Park (Southern Montebellos Sanctuary Zone) was not closed. I have closed it using the boundary for Montebello Islands Marine Park (General Use Zone). I used what is in OSM, no reference to anything else. Hopefully when the next release occurs this all gets refreshed. -
Comment from cleary
Good work. Thank you.
- 600969481, v2
- 598013073, v3
- 600966449, v3
- 598013848, v2
- 598013843, v2
- 598013425, v2
- 598013450, v2
601083708, v2601083765, v2601083706, v2601083705, v2600969499, v2600962861, v2601083700, v2600962860, v2600962764, v2598013799, v2601174702, v2601083687, v2600962659, v2
Relations (14)
- Montebello Islands Marine Park (Southern Montebellos Recreation Zone) (8404507), v3
- Montebello Islands Marine Park (Southern Montebellos Sanctuary Zone) (8403948), v17
- Montebello Islands Conservation Park (8383494), v37
- Montebello Islands Marine Park (Southern Montebellos Recreation Zone) (8404507), v4
- Montebello Islands Marine Park (Southern Montebellos Sanctuary Zone) (8403948), v18
- Montebello Islands Conservation Park (8383494), v38
- Montebello Islands Marine Park (Southern Montebellos Recreation Zone) (8404507), v5
- Montebello Islands Marine Park (Southern Montebellos Sanctuary Zone) (8403948), v19
- Montebello Islands Conservation Park (8383494), v39
- Montebello Islands Marine Park (Southern Montebellos Recreation Zone) (8404507), v6
- Montebello Islands Conservation Park (8383494), v40
- Montebello Islands Marine Park (Southern Montebellos Recreation Zone) (8404507), v7
- Montebello Islands Conservation Park (8383494), v41
- Montebello Islands Marine Park (Southern Montebellos Recreation Zone) (8404507), v8
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |