Changeset: 63325981
#fastag #traffic_signs Apply traffic_sign:direction tag to avoid problems with new iD editor as an agreement on tagging list
Closed by yopaseopor
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (14268 en) |
---|---|
source | Mapillary |
Discussion
-
Comment from Peilscheibe
I reverted this changeset because diligent tagging (e.g. about different traffic signs per direction) was removed and replaced by wrong information. This is not acceptable at all.
-
Comment from yopaseopor
This edition is about the discussion done in tagging list http://gis.19327.n8.nabble.com/Re-Traffic-sign-direction-tagging-td5923137.html about the subkeys forward and backward (my favourite option, this was not an easy decision for me but I have prefered the enable in iD and close the discussion) and the issues of iD to add the possibility to edit traffic signs. iD was big trouble to make able these editions. So in the list it was discussed the solution (change :backward /:forward subkey for traffic_sign:direction=* as the traffic_signals) , and also the iD issue solved and closed (you can see it in https://github.com/openstreetmap/iD/pull/5333 ).
So I said I will do all the modifications on the environment: presets, styles, taginfo projects, traffic_signs_maps .
And also I start to modify the "old scheme" traffic signs to the new scheme.
I have used overpass to make only these modifications - with JOSM and checking via style traffic signs were correct:-traffic_sign:forward/backward=* > traffic_sign=* & traffic_sign:direction=forward/backward/both.
So the different info per direction was not lost due to the apply of the tag traffic_sign:direction, like the traffic_signals. -
Comment from Peilscheibe
Just a few examples:
http://osmlab.github.io/osm-deep-history/#/way/25717685
http://osmlab.github.io/osm-deep-history/#/way/629964077
http://osmlab.github.io/osm-deep-history/#/way/629964082
On this ways (and a lot of others) there was a different traffic sign tagging per direction.
Why? Because in reality the ways are differently signposted per direction which has de facto and de jure implications on traffic members.
Your edit removed this diligent tagging and wrong values were contributed. This is a blatant information loss and it is wrong. -
Comment from woodpeck
This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changesets 63360720, 63359357, 63361699 where the changeset comment is: revert buggy automatic edit to traffic sign directions by yopaseopor - contrary to what is claimed, there is no consensus on the tagging list about this
- 12543048, v12
- 188301501, v8
- 237064853, v6
- Banatstraße (293797863), v5
- 361111283, v3
- 4005988, v22
- 7973639, v18
- 14487528, v12
- 21644693, v12
- 24001071, v14
- 24654597, v13
- 25717685, v15
- 27660387, v12
- Alter Ettlenschießer Weg (34509471), v12
- 39773926, v12
- 40814954, v5
- 43905407, v5
- 59996374, v7
- 74423721, v9
- 115413449, v12
- Durchlässige Sackgasse (258636197), v5
- 4316215803, v3
- 2110488, v6
- 32550024, v6
- 88907611, v7
- 122231732, v5
- 330023889, v7
- 414990238, v8
- 529970244, v5
- 538316205, v4
- 538329223, v3
- 615891427, v4
- 655153369, v5
- 873816485, v6
- Calw (935779635), v5
- 1016913979, v3
- 1317363210, v6
- AQ 99 2927 Sbg (1393033812), v5
- 1689236806, v4
- 1720567538, v4
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |