Changeset: 71643868
validator fixes
Closed by omgitsgela
Tags
changesets_count | 904 |
---|---|
created_by | iD 2.15.2 |
host | https://www.openstreetmap.org/edit |
imagery_used | None |
locale | en-US |
Discussion
-
Comment from chachafish
Hello, thank you for your changes to the map. Just so you know, the bus station at 19th and Curtis and the Civic Center Station on Broadway are actually buildings. I assume what you're trying to do here is to resolve errors flagged by a validator. It seems OSM is not quite ready to address the issue of roads and foot paths located on top of buildings and so validators will tag them as mistakes. The validator-flagged errors will most likely have to be ignored until ways located on buildings are recognized as such. I'm just guessing that's what you were trying to do here. These buildings should still be tagged as buildings. Thanks.
-
Comment from omgitsgela
I just pulled up the tags the validator did on the Civic Center Station, and it looks like it made them amenity=bus_station. Are you saying it should be using a building=* tag instead? Even without a validator, I'd consider the former tag to be a building if put as an area. What do you think?
-
Comment from chachafish
Hi, the reason this caught my eye is because both buildings had building tags, but your edits deleted them. The tag, amenity=bus_station was already there. I would recommend adding building=transportation. These are buildings and they are also bus stations. Cheers
-
Comment from omgitsgela
I managed to look up the changeset for the Civic Center, and I'm talking to #tagging about whether iD validator messed it up, and how to fix that. Do you have the way/object ID for the second station building? I can't locate it in the changeset log
Ways (2)
- Wells Fargo (581294831), v6
- Little Caesars (640509488), v7
- Subway (640509584), v11
- 1029125950, v3
- 1068206602, v3
- 1068206623, v4
- Starbucks (1158426767), v6
- E 17th Ave & Logan St (1433936266), v4
- 1932471196, v6
- 7-Eleven (2410171182), v6
- 2557874491, v3
- E 17th Ave & Clarkson St (2863575909), v3
- E 17th Ave & Pearl St (2863575911), v3
- 3110264350, v5
- 3110264351, v5
- 17th & Lincoln (3247873916), v3
- 3287230561, v4
- 3287230768, v3
- 3287230769, v4
- 3287238473, v2
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |