Changeset: 77785078
remove undiscussed, automatic addition of transliterated names and IDs to railway stations
Closed by woodpeck_repair
Tags
bot | yes |
---|---|
created_by | osmtools/30252 (linux) |
Discussion
-
Comment from Yevgeny Gromov
What's wrong with ESR codes of railway stations? Are they illegal or where should they be discussed?
-
Comment from Komяpa
Hello, why was this changeset reverted without discussion with local communities?
-
Comment from Komяpa
Question about need of this revert was raised in https://t.me/byosm
-
Comment from KKS
a bit strange why removed name:uk here and others
https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/2014435619/history -
Comment from woodpeck
The reason for this revert is that these automated edits have not been - as far as I could see - discussed before. Several users had complained about station names like "123 km" being transliterated/translated into a multitude of languages (e.g. 14 names in https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/3781302157/history) even though we have a clear rule that we don't use name:xx for transliterations/translations.
The ESR code was added by the same undiscussed automated process so I removed it too while I was at it, though I'm happy to reinstate it if the community agrees it is useful.
-
Comment from KKS
So why u remove name:uk and leave name:ru here - https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/2014435619/history ?
So it should be only name=* tag with native name only. Here in Ukraine we have only one language - Ukranian, so why we have name:ru after revert?
- Котиково (1290233991), v4
- Глиняне (1306531488), v7
- Обвідна (1387194231), v10
- 13 км (1055383366), v5
- Титан (1005053466), v5
- Кооптах (1132753587), v6
- Назрань (1211384626), v7
- 60 км (1214938281), v7
- 106 км (1215727533), v8
- Сура (1223264003), v9
- Чашкан (1248664013), v6
- 226 км (1271074795), v8
- 35 км (1028677678), v10
- 1169 км (1035466148), v5
- 397 км (1037915523), v7
- Миннибаево (1028676346), v7
- 4 км (1137585959), v8
- Маслово (1141176586), v7
- Зарудинці (1213258198), v6
- Велижановка (1271074785), v8
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |